Tom Nash
patreon
Bond ETFs vs. Individual Bonds vs. Money Market Accounts - Complete Bond 101 Tutorial For Beginners
🕑 Added 2025-01-11 06:34:00 +0000 UTCBonds 101: The Grandpa Investment With a Modern Twist
If you’ve been in the stock market for more than five minutes, you’ve undoubtedly heard someone mention bonds, usually referred to as the “grandpa” investment or “safe” harbor when stocks get choppy.
But guess what? Boring isn’t always bad, and in some cases, it might just be the exact flavor of boring you need to shore up your portfolio and help you sleep at night.
In this primer, I’m going to give you a deep dive on what bonds are, why they matter, how to buy them, when to consider them, and what the difference is between buying a bond ETF (like BND) versus buying individual Treasuries or using a money market account.
We’ll also address the question that’s probably at the top of your mind: “Is now a good time to buy bonds?” So buckle up and grab a coffee (maybe two); we’re going on a joyride through bond land.
Table of Contents
What Are Bonds, and Why Should You Care?
The 3 Big Ways To Own Bonds
Bond ETFs
Individual Bonds
Money Market Accounts/Funds
Bonds vs. Equities: The Unholy Marriage
Interest Rates: The Puppet Master of Bond Prices
When To Buy Bonds: Hot Market vs. Fearful Market
Crafting a Bond Strategy: Duration, Credit Risk, and More
Common Pitfalls and Myths
Final Thoughts
1. What Are Bonds, and Why Should You Care?
Definition in Plain English
A bond is basically a fancy IOU. When you buy a bond, you’re lending your money to either a government (like the U.S. Treasury) or a corporation (Apple, Tesla, your Uncle Bob’s questionable start up though that last one doesn’t trade on the open market, obviously). In exchange for your cash, the borrower (the issuer of the bond) promises to pay you a fixed interest rate called a coupon for the life of the bond, and then pay back your principal (the original amount you lent) when the bond matures.
Why Bother With Boring IOUs?
Imagine you’re 100% in stocks, and 2020 happens. Stocks crash, and your net worth does a triple backflip off a cliff. Now, if you’re young, fearless, or just borderline insane, you might say, “Stocks only go up over time,” and hold tight. But if you’re closer to retirement or just risk averse, you might want some cushion. That’s where bonds come in. They tend to move differently from stocks; when equities are tanking, bonds might hold up better (especially if we’re talking about high-quality government bonds).
They can act like a shock absorber for your portfolio.
The “Grandpa” Reputation
Bonds are seen as conservative because they don’t typically offer the same explosive returns that you can get from the stock market. You’re not going to 10x your money with a Treasury bond. But guess what? Some people like not losing 50% in a downturn. For them, a steady coupon payment is more attractive than a trip to the casino.
2. The 3 Big Ways To Own Bonds
So you’ve decided you want some exposure to bonds. Great. Now you have to figure out how to own them. Essentially, there are three main vehicles:
Bond ETFs
Individual Bonds
Money Market Accounts/Funds
Let’s break each one down.
2.1 Bond ETFs (Example: BND)
Overview
A bond ETF (Exchange Traded Fund) is basically a basket of bonds bundled into a single ticker. Think of it like a “greatest hits” album for bonds, where you buy one share and instantly own a slice of hundreds, sometimes thousands, of different bonds.
Pros
Instant Diversification: With a single purchase, you get exposure to government, corporate, or even international bonds (depending on the ETF’s strategy).
Liquidity: ETFs trade on the stock market just like any stock. You can buy or sell them instantly during market hours.
Low Barrier to Entry: You don’t need $1,000 or $10,000 to buy one bond at a time. You can buy just one share of an ETF, which might cost $80, $100, or whatever it’s trading at.
Cons
Expense Ratios: There’s usually a small management fee. While bond ETFs often have low fees, it’s still a drag on your returns.
Less Control: You’re at the mercy of the fund manager’s choices. If you’re a control freak about which specific bonds you own, an ETF might not scratch that itch.
Price Fluctuation: ETFs can lose or gain value daily based on interest rates, market sentiment, or even just random panic selling. You’re not guaranteed to get the exact net asset value at all times.
Ideal For
Beginners or casual investors who want bond exposure without the hassle of individual bond selection.
People who value simplicity and liquidity.
2.2 Individual Bonds (Example: U.S. Treasuries)
Overview
When you buy an individual bond, you choose the specific issuer (like the U.S. government, Apple, or Ford) and the specific maturity date and coupon. You lend them your money directly, cutting out the aggregator or manager.
Pros
Predictable Income (If Held to Maturity): You know exactly what your coupon rate is and when the bond matures, you’ll get your principal back, assuming the issuer doesn’t default.
No Ongoing Management Fees: You might pay a transaction fee when you buy or sell, but there’s no annual expense ratio.
Cons
Bigger Capital Requirements: Typically, bonds are sold in $1,000 increments. Some brokers might offer fractional bonds, but it’s not as common as buying ETF shares.
Liquidity Issues: If you need to sell before maturity, you might not get a good price, especially for corporate or municipal bonds that don’t have as deep a market as Treasuries.
Ideal For
Investors who want absolute clarity about yield and maturity.
Those comfortable with a bit more complexity and less liquidity.
People who like the “buy and hold” approach and plan to see the bond through maturity.
2.3 Money Market Accounts/Funds
Overview
Money market accounts (MMAs) or money market funds invest in short-term, high-quality debt instruments like Treasury bills, certificates of deposit (CDs), or commercial paper from top rated companies. They’re usually short term (less than one year).
Pros
Stability: Typically, these are very low risk. You won’t get hammered by interest rate swings like you could with longer term bonds.
Liquidity: You can usually move money in and out easily. Some accounts even allow check writing privileges.
Decent Yield in Rising Rate Environments: When the Federal Reserve hikes rates, money market yields can tick up relatively quickly.
Cons
Lower Returns (Usually): You might earn less than you would by locking into a longer term bond or taking on some credit risk.
Not for Long Term Growth: Over many years, inflation can erode these returns. They’re more for parking cash or short-term savings.
Ideal For
People who want to park their money safely while they decide where to invest next.
Individuals who need their cash accessible, like an emergency fund.
3. Bonds vs. Equities: The Unholy Marriage
You might be thinking: “I’m already 100% in stocks, and I love that sweet upside potential. Why should I even bother with these snail paced bonds?” Let’s talk about portfolio theory for a second, don’t worry, I’ll keep it brief.
Volatility Cushion: By mixing stocks and bonds, you reduce overall volatility. Imagine your portfolio is a cocktail. 100% vodka might be fun in college, but at some point, adding a splash of tonic water (bonds) can spare you some severe hangovers.
Asset Allocation: If you’re young with a stable income and a high risk tolerance, 100% equities might be fine. But if you’re older, or just more cautious, some bonds can help preserve capital.
Rebalancing Magic: When stocks tank, bonds often hold their value (especially Treasuries). You can sell some bonds high and buy stocks low. In a bull market, you might do the opposite. This rebalancing can enhance long-term returns.
4. Interest Rates: The Puppet Master of Bond Prices
You can’t talk about bonds without mentioning interest rates, the alpha and omega of bond performance. Here’s how it works in plain language:
When interest rates go up, new bonds offer higher yields. The old bonds (with lower coupons) become less attractive, so their prices drop.
When interest rates go down, new bonds offer lower yields, making old bonds (with higher coupons) more desirable. Their prices go up.
It’s like real estate: If a brand new house next door is selling for half the price, the value of your house would likely go down, too. Bonds are no different.
But you might not care about these price swings if you plan to hold a bond until maturity. At maturity, the issuer (hopefully) pays you the face value, regardless of the market price in between. However, if you’re holding a bond ETF, you don’t have a single maturity date to cling to. The ETF constantly buys and sells bonds, so you’re at the mercy of the market’s interest rate gyrations.
5. When To Buy Bonds: Hot Market vs. Fearful Market
I always say: “The best time to buy bonds is a hot market.” Let’s break that down:
Hot Market (Booming Economy, Stocks Surging):
When everyone and their grandma is piling into stocks, bonds can fall out of favor. This can push bond prices down and yields up. If you notice that bond yields are attractive compared to stock dividends, that might be an interesting time to lock in those higher interest payments.Fearful Market (High Volatility, VIX Spiking):
When the market is terrified, investors often rush into “safe” assets like government bonds, driving prices up and yields down. Could this be a bad time to buy? Not necessarily, if your goal is safety or capital preservation, you might still buy. But you won’t be getting those sweet yields you might see in calmer or “hotter” times.Timing the Market = Sisyphus’s Rock:
Look, nobody has a crystal ball. The Federal Reserve sets short-term rates, and the bond market sets long-term rates. There are so many macro variables: inflation, GDP growth, unemployment, war, pandemics, that trying to pinpoint the perfect time to buy is near impossible.
A common strategy is dollar cost averaging: buy a bit each month or quarter, smoothing out the ride.
6. Crafting a Bond Strategy: Duration, Credit Risk, and More
If you’re new to bonds, you might hear terms like “duration,” “yield to maturity,” “credit risk,” and think, “What is this alien language?” Let’s decode some of these concepts.
6.1 Duration
Definition: Duration is a measure of a bond’s sensitivity to interest rates. A higher duration means the bond’s price is more sensitive to rate changes.
Rule of Thumb:
Short-Term Bonds (Low Duration): Less price volatility, but usually lower yields.
Long-Term Bonds (High Duration): Higher price volatility, but potentially higher yields.
If you think rates will go up, you generally want shorter-duration bonds or money market funds to avoid the price drop. If you think rates will go down, longer duration bonds can lock in higher coupons and see price appreciation.
6.2 Credit Risk
Investment Grade vs. High Yield: Government bonds (especially U.S. Treasuries) are seen as “risk free” for default purposes (though they can still fluctuate in price). Investment grade corporate bonds are typically from stable companies that are unlikely to default. High yield (“junk”) bonds come from riskier issuers with a higher chance of default, but they pay bigger coupons to compensate for that risk.
Ratings Agencies: You’ll see ratings like AAA, BBB, or CCC from agencies like Moody’s or S&P. Higher ratings (AAA) mean lower risk but lower yields.
6.3 Yield to Maturity (YTM)
What It Is: The total return you can expect if you hold the bond until it matures, assuming all coupon payments are made and reinvested.
Why It Matters: Coupon rate alone can be misleading if you’re buying a bond above or below par (face value). YTM factors in the price you pay, the coupons, and the face value redemption.
6.4 Building a Bond Ladder
Concept: Instead of buying one bond that matures in 10 years, you buy a “ladder” of bonds with staggered maturities: 1 year, 2 years, 5 years, 10 years, etc.
Benefits: As each bond matures, you reinvest the principal into a new bond at the prevailing interest rate. This approach can help you manage interest rate risk and provide a steady stream of maturing bonds in case you need cash.
7. Common Pitfalls and Myths
Let’s clear up some misunderstandings that often come up when people talk about bonds:
“Bonds Never Lose Money.”
False. If you buy a bond and the market’s interest rates spike, the value of your bond can drop. If you sell before maturity, you might book a loss. Even if you hold to maturity, there’s always the risk of default (albeit very low for Treasuries).“I Can Just Buy a Bond ETF and Forget It.”
Well, sort of. ETFs do simplify things, but they still fluctuate in value. If interest rates go up, the net asset value of the ETF can go down, even though you’re collecting dividends.“High Yield Is Always Better.”
High yield literally means high risk. You’re basically taking a bet that the higher coupon compensates for the higher chance that the issuer might go belly up.“I Don’t Need Bonds; I’m Young.”
That might be true if you’re comfortable with extreme volatility and have a long time horizon. But even young investors can benefit from some bonds for portfolio stability, especially if they get spooked by big drawdowns.“I’ll Wait Until Rates Peak.”
Good luck trying to call the exact top. Markets are forward looking, and rates don’t ring a bell when they’ve peaked.
8. Final Thoughts
1. There’s No One Size Fits All
Everyone’s situation is unique. Some folks might need 40–50% in bonds if they’re nearing retirement or simply can’t stomach wild equity swings. Others might be fine with just 10%. The point is to understand how bonds can stabilize your portfolio and potentially offer a decent yield.
2. Timing Bonds Is Hard
As I mentioned, waiting for the “perfect time” to buy bonds is like waiting for a clear day in London, it might never come. A better approach could be to dollar cost average or to buy bonds in tranches over time.
3. Know Your Goals
Are you looking for short-term parking of cash? A money market fund might be best. Want broad exposure and simplicity? A bond ETF does the trick. Want total control and a known yield at maturity? Individual bonds are your friend.
4. Keep an Eye on Fees
Whether you’re buying ETFs or individual bonds, watch out for fees. ETFs have expense ratios, while individual bonds might come with bid-ask spreads or broker commissions. These costs can eat into your returns.
5. Rebalance, Rebalance, Rebalance
Part of having bonds in your portfolio is the ability to rebalance when equities or bonds swing in value. This disciplined approach can help you buy low and sell high, even if you do it unconsciously by sticking to your allocation targets.
6. Grandpa’s Investment Still Has Life
Yes, bonds are the slow-and-steady friend in your portfolio. But “boring” can sometimes be exactly what you need, especially when the stock market is throwing a temper tantrum. Don’t dismiss them just because they aren’t “to the moon” rocket ships.
