FapsCommunity
dragonheartednovels from patreon
dragonheartednovels patreon

[Archived Short Story] The Merchant's Bet

🕑 Added 2022-08-31 06:24:53 +0000 UTC

Comments

Carl Mason

Yeaaahhh... You know what! You, my good sir, have inspired me.

Akhier Dragonheart

That's what I mean. Even in a "real world" the skills like haggle all end up being nonsense.

Carl Mason

I mean even in stories with "real people" the skills are based on those same systems except with vastly more power. A merchant has the ability to swindle a random villager for his savings, his home, his first born, wife and mother in payment for a cast iron pot, and the character won't walk away! It is just ...stupid. It's stupid! How does that Haggle skill exist in a situation like that? I see them in stories like "Magic Smithing " and "Singer, Sailor, Merchant, Mage" which are otherwise incredible stories. A chance for up to a 5% increase in favorable terms is mostly reasonable, the skills that I see in stories are just ridiculous and stupid. But you make a good point about the basis of these skills.

Akhier Dragonheart

The problem is that most merchant skills tend to be based upon game systems instead of actual real life skills. So there will be a haggle skill but all it actually does is automatically reduce the buy price by 5% and raise your sell price by 5%. You know, instead of making the person better at haggling. The automatic changes make sense when dealing with a robotic NPC, but doesn't work all that well when they're actually people, even if in a game setting.

Carl Mason

That was a good twist, I was just about to now out myself after remembering how little I generally like merchant skills. Those skills tend to be about artificially manipulating markets and that just bothers me, I however love merchant skills that make the merchant better at their job rather than increasing their margin. A travelling merchant should, of course, have Smooth Roads and be able to Avoid Hazards, maybe a good one can even Expedite Shipping. I love all professional Skills except merchant skills designed to Inflate Prices. But this had a nice fun twist that brought us away from the actual negotiations, I like it.

Akhier Dragonheart

It obviously does, the problem is writing that story is harder than writing the story of some plucky adventurer. While most people won't have experience with either, in the end it is much simpler to talk about smashing monsters than it is to weave a tale about all the high level intrigue and such.

Rory

That was a fun read. If you're curious the inspiration for the prompt was that I'd read a few stories involving a merchant guild master, but the role they played was almost always just being wealthy and investing in the MC's bold venture. I felt that a position of guild master should really have something more to it.

Akhier Dragonheart

Story written from the prompt provided by Rory. Prompt Below: "Merchant Skill Battle - Two neighboring kingdoms have decided to sign a new trade agreement involving their resources, produce and services. Each kingdom sends their Merchant's Guild Master as representatives along with specialist advisors and guards. As far as the guards are concerned, its a rather boring affair. For the merchants though, it is a back and forth battle of Skills like [Logistics], [Foresight], [Cost vs Gain], [Barter], [Detect Falsehood], [Sense Motive], etc."


More Creators