Episode 201: The Conservative, Faux-Erudite Rise of Nuance Trolling
🕑 Added 2024-05-15 16:01:10 +0000 UTC“Here's why creating single-payer health care in America is so hard,” explained Harold Pollack in Vox in 2016. “The benefits of climate action…are diffuse and hard to pin down,” shrugged a Foreign Affairs article in 2020. “A nuanced view of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict,” presented Aliza Pilichowski in The Jerusalem Post in 2023.
Each of the above is an example of something that can be called "Nuance Trolling": The insistence that some major beneficial development like single-payer healthcare, ending wars and bombing campaigns, or the mitigation, even cessation, of climate change is impossible because the situation is too nuanced, the plan too lacking in detail, the goal too hard to achieve, the public isn’t behind it or some other bad faith “concern” that makes bold action an impossibility. Nuance Trolls present power-serving defeatism as savvy pragmatism, claiming over and over that no good, meaningful change can happen because no version of it will ever work.
Nuance and complexity, of course, are real, legitimate things. Political, social, environmental, and economic dynamics often are complicated. But Nuance Trolls abuse this self-evident truism, using it as a mode of analysis designed to weaken and water down movements for change that seek actual, material solutions to political problems, and instead promoting inaction to ensure the continuation of the already oppressive status quo.
On this episode, we examine the rise of the Nuance Troll and analyze the media’s selective invocation of “nuance” in order to stifle urgent movements for social justice, reducing poverty, curbing climate chaos and ending occupation and war.
Our guest is Natasha Lennard.
Guest
Natasha Lennard (@natashalennard) is columnist for The Intercept, whose work has also appeared in The Nation, Bookforum, Dissent, and The New York Times, among many other outlets. She is also Associate Director of the Creative Publishing & Critical Journalism graduate program at the New School for Social Research, and the author of two books. Her most recent is "Being Numerous: Essays on Non-Fascist Life," which was published by Verso Books in 2019.
**
Show Notes
Mary McCarthy | November 9, 1967 | New York Review of Books
On Withdrawing from Vietnam: An Exchange
Diana Trilling, Mary McCarthy | January 18, 1968 | New York Review of Books
Beyond Vietnam: A Time to Break Silence
Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. | April 4, 1967
The Paths to Net Zero: How Technology Can Save the Planet
Inês Azevedo, Michael R. Davidson, Jesse D. Jenkins, Valerie J. Karplus, and David G. Victor | April 13, 2020 | Foreign Affairs
Here's why creating single-payer health care in America is so hard
Harold Pollack | January 16, 2016 | Vox
Bernie Sanders’s Bill Gets America Zero Percent Closer to Single Payer
Jonathan Chait | September 13, 2017 | New York Magazine
Adam Johnson | September 21, 2017 | The Los Angeles Times
Adam Johnson | December 16, 2022 | The Column
Why we split the world into good and evil – and make decisions we regret
Amanda Ripley | January 4, 2024 | The Washington Post
‘I Feel a Human Deterioration’
Lulu Garcia-Navarro (interview with Etgar Keret) | October 27, 2023 | The New York Times
***
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here. You can find transcripts of past episodes, interviews and News Briefs here.
****
Citations Merch

Remember that the Citations Needed merch store is open! Please consider further supporting the show by picking up a t-shirt, tank top, sweatshirt, tote or coffee mug for yourself or your favorite Citations fan (or everyone you know!).
*****
Credits
Senior Producer: Florence Barrau-Adams
Producer: Julianne Tveten
Production Assistant: Trendel Lightburn
Newsletter: Marco Cartolano
Transcription: Mahnoor Imran
Music: Grandaddy
******
Comments
Chica del Río
Why is the title of this segment on nuance trolling pinning it on "conservative" speakers? I would agree with that if you include the Democratic Party as conservatives also. For instance the Biden administration has been advised by Dick Cheney's past neocon Iraq War advisors like Victoria Nuland, involved in handing out cookies during the 2014 Ukraine coup and caught on tape discussing who the US wanted put in the successor government. We have the Republicans and Republican light currently with Liz Cheney called on for support frequently. The Dems are pushing a war that they help provoke and they certainly are masters of nuance trolling to justify establishment interests and war interests. Including about genocide.
Well aged meme
helps keeps
Cory Clay
Thank you so much!
Lizbeth Kimble
Mariame Kaba. She's got some really good books, and I've heard her as a guest on numerous podcasts.
Cory Clay
Could someone tell me the person she mentioned regarding prison abolition? I thought I heard Maryanne Carver but I might not be correct.
Gillian Rosheuvel
Obama's fucking weasely word salad is so fucking insufferable.
Unruly Quaker
Excellent ep, thank you! Kept thinking of Selina Meyer (Veep), who might be the perfect example of nuance-trolling. “I see you! Oh yes, well, this issue is … it’s nuanced.”
Ciaran Colley
Oh, and nuance trolls are also signed-up members of the 'How You Gonna Pay For That?' Club.
Ciaran Colley
The nuance trolls also tend to be the types who love using the phrase 'don't let perfect be the enemy of the good' - woe betide you, however, if your preferred policy solutions aren't (a) immediate and (b) completely externality-free.
Renee
Fantastic topic and episode, and guest Natasha Lennard blew me away with her brilliance. Thank you for sharing this with us all.
🤷🏼♀️
Thanks for this. I’ve been apoplectically frothing at the mouth as I rant and screech about the cynical deploying of nuance to prevent any meaningful advancement of a goal to everyone around me for years
Matthew
Natasha Lennard is possibly the funniest guest you've ever had on the show; stoked for this! Edit: Brilliant episode; Natasha's deployment of Wittgenstein in this context is spot-on, kudos