Episode 181: US Media's 5 Most Popular Revisionist Tropes About the Iraq and Vietnam Wars
🕑 Added 2023-05-10 15:04:43 +0000 UTC"Charting a different course in the Vietnam War to fewer deaths and a better end," muses a book review in the Washington Post. "The Vietnam War was begun in good faith, by decent people," a Ken Burns PBS documentary tells us. "The Iraq War Reconsidered," reads a headline from The Atlantic.
Often, especially when an anniversary of a U.S. invasion or withdrawal rolls around, we're told that the devastation wrought by the US war machine was complicated, flawed, but ultimately necessary if not beneficial. Sure, the United States has killed millions, destabilized power structures, wrecked communities and economies, lied about the reasons for doing it all, and drawn the ire of people throughout the world. But, in hindsight, many in U.S. media insists, a horrible act of war from a world superpower wasn't an unequivocal, deliberate, and needless crime against humanity, but somewhere between a misunderstood righteous cause and a bumbling, good faith mistake motivated by humanitarian concerns.
An ideological system of reassurance therefore emerges. Once wars are broadly viewed as either wrong or a quote-unquote "failure" in the popular imagination — as in the case of Vietnam and Iraq — a cottage industry of punditry and pseudo-history emerges in the subsequent years designed to soothe the egos of elites and muddy the waters of both memory and reality for casual media consumers.
Put another way: we all see a dead body on the floor, no one can doubt this. No one can reasonably argue the destruction of Vietnam and Iraq didn't happen. So, this cottage industry springs into action, on behalf of those that caused the death, working to get the guilty party a charge of third degree manslaughter rather than murder. It was an accident, they were mistaken, they had bad intelligence, they were driven by concerns for freedom and human rights.
After all, those who destroyed Vietnam remained in power well into the 2000s. And those who destroyed Iraq currently run our major publications, universities, nonprofits, and think tanks. They still even run the country itself. So the incentive to make sure they all plead guilty to third degree manslaughter rather than first degree murder is tremendous, otherwise, we’re just a country led by war criminals — and this simply cannot be. We need absolution. We must remain, when all is said and done, innocent.
On this week's episode, we’ll explore the war revisionism industry, breaking down five ways in which media seek to sanitize and justify even the most notoriously unpopular and horrific U.S.-led and backed wars — namely Vietnam and Iraq — as unpleasant, imperfect, mistaken, but ultimately incidental byproducts of a noble and righteous empire that, above all, meant well.
Our guest is The Intercept's Jon Schwarz.
*
Guest
Jon Schwarz (@schwarz) is a senior writer for The Intercept. Jon's amazing archive of commentary, analysis and criticism can be found at A Tiny Revolution.
**
Show Notes
The Architects of the Iraq War: Where Are They Now?
Jon Schwarz | March 15, 2023 | The Intercept
US Media's Iraq War Pushers 20 Years On: Where Are They Now? Rich and Influential.
Adam Johnson | March 17, 2023 | The Real News Network
20 Years On, a Question Lingers About Iraq: Why Did the U.S. Invade?
Max Fisher | March 18, 2023 | The New York Times
Iraq War Apologism Is Alive and Well
Branko Marcetic | March 21, 2023 | Jacobin
Whatever They Say Now, America’s Political and Media Elites Overwhelmingly Supported the Iraq War
Joe Renouard | March 21, 2023 | ZNetwork
Michael Brenes | March 20, 2023 | Contingent Magazine
How to Write an Iraq War Apologia
Elspeth Reeve | March 20, 2013 | The Atlantic
All History Is Revisionist History
James M. Banner, Jr. | Summer 2022 | Humanities
20 Years After U.S. Invasion, Iraq Is a Freer Place, but Not a Hopeful One
Alissa J. Rubin | March 18, 2023 | The New York Times
Charles P. Pierce | Mach 20, 2013 | Esquire
Mistakes, Excuses and Painful Lessons From the Iraq War
Ezra Klein | March 19, 2013 | Bloomberg
Revisionism as a Substitute for Victory
Mark Atwood Lawrence | July 6, 2018 | The Common Reader
Vietnam Revisionism and the Ugly American
Mark Atwood Lawrence | June 5, 2018 | Lawfare
John Ganz | February 20, 2018 | The Baffler
Another Warmonger Rewarded for Being Wrong on Iraq War
Adam Johnson | February 1, 2018 | FAIR
Why Are We in the Middle East?
Richard Beck | Fall 2016 | n+1
***
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here. You can find transcripts of past episodes and News Briefs here.
****
Citations Merch
Remember that the Citations Needed merch store is open! Please consider further supporting the show by picking up a t-shirt, tank top, sweatshirt, tote or coffee mug for yourself or your favorite Citations fan (or everyone you know!).
*****
Credits
Senior Producer: Florence Barrau-Adams
Producer: Julianne Tveten
Production Assistant: Trendel Lightburn
Newsletter: Marco Cartolano
Transcription: Morgan McAslan
Music: Grandaddy
******
Comments
natfos 💌
30 minutes in and i need to take a break because i'm getting so pissed off and just wanna start shouting about this in ppls faces at work lol. the way anyone could ever say or buy that decimating a country through every means possible is 'spreading democracy' just makes me see RED!!!
Mark Schneider
Much appreciated coverage, guys. So you reminded me I called out some of my Republican ghoul colleagues at work some time after the Iraq war started, but it made no difference to their (pre-closed) minds, obviously. One idiot played stupid, "Mark, you couldn't have known there were no WMDs in Iraq at the time!! Literally NO ONE in the world knew that!" I stated clearly that (a) US Marine & UN Weapons Inspector Scott Ritter was sharing the no WMDs facts at the time, & (b) I knew as a history teacher that the purported reasons for the US entry into the Spanish American War, earlier US-Mexico war, Gulf of Tonkin fake incident to start US entry to Vietnam were all faked, etc.. Might as well have been speaking Esperanto!! (This dude was a dummy who literally called Obama a lefty "Socialist" in debates for the HS students during the 08 & 12 election shows.) I talked to his zombie buddy later, our conversation ended with him saying, Well, look, everything is going to be OKAY, anyway!! Meaning okay for HIS white, Catholic NorCal family. The people of Iraq & the region were entirely forgotten, nonexistent-- I guess like Golda Meir more than once said there simply "were no Palestinian people" in 1948.
Gillian Rosheuvel
😆
Shawn A
And an enlightened corporate underwriter, Bank of America!
Great job guys. Jon's closing remarks were biting (and fantastic)!
Lizbeth Kimble
This is also timely in that Kissinger is about to turn 100 in a couple weeks. Talk about someone who hasn't had the decency to shuffle off his mortal coil...
Gillian Rosheuvel
Re the Ken Burns Vietnam documentary...I mean what did we expect from something funded by the Koch brothers
natfos 💌
when citations needed drops on the clock and i can use the transcript to read it >>>