Episode 180: Havana Syndrome and the Power of Mainstream, Acceptable Conspiracy Theories
🕑 Added 2023-05-03 14:05:51 +0000 UTC"I Was A Teenage Conspiracy Theorist," The Atlantic magazine playfully titled a 2020 essay. "Choose your reality: Trust wanes, conspiracy theories rise," reported The Associated Press in 2022. "Do You Know Someone Who Believes in Conspiracy Theories? We Want to Hear About It," wrote The New York Times last year.
Fears of "conspiracy theories" are a common trope in the U.S. media, a worry that's grown more acute with the rise of QAnon, anti-vaxx sentiment, anti-semitism and a host of other dangerous theories that unduly rot brains throughout the country. To a great extent, this understandable: Many ideas that meet the definition of "conspiracy theories" are, indeed, baseless and dangerous and can direct people's political energy and resources into wasteful, racist, and downright stupid rabbit holes.
But that fact shouldn't delegitimize or foreclose all skepticism of those in power, but too often the term "conspiracy theory" is used to do just that. Repeatedly, media lump together so-called conspiracy theories, regardless of their accuracy, rationale, and ideology: at once, UFO chasers, QAnon, and the Black Panther Party being subject to FBI disruption are somehow placed in the same category of paranoid kooks. At the same time, unproven, and often debunked ideas advanced by media that also meet the definition of "conspiracy theories" — such as Saddam Hussein being behind 9/11 or so-called Havana syndrome — are treated as unassailable, meriting ongoing investigation, limitless resources, and of course, utmost solemnity.
On this episode, we detail the double standards applied to conspiracy theories inside and outside of the realm of U.S. corporate media. We’ll examine the development of the concept of conspiracy theories and the media's selective invocations of the term to discredit real grievances directed at American power and the U.S. government, and moreover, how power-friendly conspiracies — namely those focused on Enemy States like the Havana Syndrome narrative — are permitted to fester and grow without pushback because their red yarn dot connecting implicates the right lists of Acceptable Bad Guys.
Our guest is Jacobin writer Branko Marcetic.
*
Guest
Branko Marcetic (@BMarchetich) is a staff writer for Jacobin magazine and the author of the book Yesterday's Man: The Case Against Joe Biden (Verso, 2020)
**
Show Notes
The Paranoid Style in American Politics
Richard Hofstadter | November 1964 | Harper's Magazine
Adam Johnson | August 10, 2017 | FAIR
‘Havana syndrome’ not caused by energy weapon or foreign adversary, intelligence review finds
Shane Harris and John Hudson | March 1, 2023 | The Washington Post
Pentagon Requests $36 Million For Havana Syndrome
Ken Klippenstein | April 20, 2023 | The Intercept
Most ‘Havana Syndrome’ Cases Unlikely Caused by Foreign Power, C.I.A. Says
Julian E. Barnes | January 20, 2022 | The New York Times
Washington’s “Havana Syndrome” Promoters Have a Lot to Answer For
Natalie Shure | January 28, 2022 | The New Republic
A Declassified State Department Report Says Microwaves Didn’t Cause “Havana Syndrome”
Dan Vergano | September 30, 2021 | BuzzFeed News
Richard Stone | February 15, 2018 | Science
The French Revolution as Illuminati Conspiracy
Livia Gershon | September 28, 2020 | JStor Daily
I Was A Teenage Conspiracy Theorist
Ellen Cushing | May 13, 2020 | The Atlantic
British Conservatism, the Illuminati, and the Conspiracy Theory of the French Revolution, 1797–1802
Michael Taylor | Spring 2014 | Eighteenth-Century Studies
Skin in the Game: How Antisemitism Animates White Nationalism
Eric K. Ward | June 29, 2017 | Public Eye
On the Origins of the Blood Libel
Matthew Wills | October 8, 2021 | JStor Daily
Mike Caulfield | December 24, 2018 | Hapgood
Book Review: The Rhetoric of Conspiracy in Ancient Athens
Andrew Wolpert and Victoria Pagán | March 14, 2007 | Bryn Mawr Classical Review
***
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here. You can find transcripts of past episodes and News Briefs here.
****
Citations Merch
Remember that the Citations Needed merch store is open! Please consider further supporting the show by picking up a t-shirt, tank top, sweatshirt, tote or coffee mug for yourself or your favorite Citations fan (or everyone you know!).
*****
Credits
Senior Producer: Florence Barrau-Adams
Producer: Julianne Tveten
Production Assistant: Trendel Lightburn
Newsletter: Marco Cartolano
Transcription: Morgan McAslan
Music: Grandaddy
******
Comments
Jarrod
Agree with this! And this is a good podcast episode with a Jewish comrade on this topic! https://prolespod.libsyn.com/episode-31-stalin-was-a-mensch-a-look-at-the-antisemitism-of-the-ussr
@jdixvx
As conspiracy theories go, Russiagate got far more traction and has been far more consequential than Havana Syndrome, and it's not close. A good share Democrats still believe it and it watered the soil from which support for the current proxy war in Ukraine grew and is being sustained. Far more damaging and the nonstop coverage helped to externalize and deflect from Democrats own failure to beat Donald Trump in 2016. The Trump is "very" sympathetic and that Russia never denied hacking the DNC server support your 95% confidence that they did it feel like a way to bothsides the issue in order to placate your more mainstream liberal-left listeners Havana Syndrome is an easy target comparatively. Where is the episode on Russiagate? Have Aaron Maté on and pose some tough questions to him. That would be a great conversation that I think would offer your audience clarity on the issue.
V K
It didn't, but now his career did.
V K
To be fair, I'm willing to make up a conspiracy theory to help fix climate change, if that's actually going to work.
Mike
Remember when that Malaysian airlines flight went missing and CNN went nuts devoting what felt like months of coverage to it? Don Lemon even suggested it might have been sucked into a black hole.
Eli
who do I have to pay to get citations needed merch that says "have you seen a semi truck sized brain lazer?"
Citations Needed
Please do if you can! We’d love to replace our reading with the original audio (it’s always preferable)
Greta P
I'm an archivist at NPR. I also don't know exactly why that story audio isn't online, but maybe I can figure out how use your "conspiracy theory" to argue for more resources to get our out-of-date Real media audio links from 2003 more comprehensively updated.
sensorsweep
i would like to formally submit my application for membership in 'Marginal Paranoids'. not looking to be up front, maybe 3rd guitarist. i'm happy to stand in the back by one of the drummers
Mitch Schiller
Great episode on conspiracy in general! I'd challenge you on claims of "Stalin being antisemitic". These are simply lies about the USSR. Stalin has more than one writing directly on the subject, as does Lenin. Both were adamantly against this. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1931/01/12.html I'd be remiss not to also mention https://archive.is/BapMx Great episode, don't mean to be rude, just food for thought 💭 love the show! And Cuba ❤️
natfos 💌
oh ik y'all are about to go IN
David
First as per usual