Episode 173: How to Sell Police Crackdowns on Homeless People to Liberals
🕑 Added 2022-12-21 14:40:39 +0000 UTC"The city has had 125 daily interactions," New York Mayor Eric Adams tells the Daily News. "We’re working to solve the homelessness crisis, with innovative mental health interventions," San Francisco Mayor London Breed tells reporters. The city needs to "clean up homeless encampments," countless city officials tell us. Everywhere we turn, our elected –– largely Democratic –– governors and mayors are talking about quote "solving the homelessness crisis" without specifying what, exactly, these plans entail.
Saying elected officials are going to harass and displace the homeless population until they’re incarcerated or leave our city and wealthy neighborhood sounds unseemly and inhumane. But this –– minus the occasional and insufficient attempts to offer public housing –– is more or less the strategy of most big cities: Send in police to "sweep up" encampments, enforce low-level drug offenses and ticket the unhoused for loitering and camping, But saying this is the plan sounds mean, so, over the past couple of years, as America’s housing crisis has grown more acute and the end of COVID-era tenant protections unceremoniously sunset, a cottage industry of pleasant sounding euphemisms have emerged to sell police-led homeless crackdowns to squeamish liberals.
The right-wing, historically, is fairly upfront with its bootstrap, austerity logic. And they, for the most part, don't run major cities where the homelessness crisis manifests. Liberals and progressives –– short on resources and political incentive to actually address the underlying issues –– need to sell the same played out, discredited carceral attempts at removing Visible Poverty but, unlike Republicans, can't do so in explicit terms. So, a PR regime emerges to paper over these glaring contradictions, leading to heretofore unseen levels of bullshittery.
On this episode, we going to examine four popular euphemisms employed by "blue" city leaders to sell the same old carceral playbook to their wary, self-identifying progressive constituents, how these programs do little to address the central issues of a lack of affordable and free housing, and how city leaders –– with wildly insufficient federal support for housing, a foaming anti-homeless media and suffering from institutional political cowardice –– are left with little more than meaningless "emergency declarations," Tough Guy, Take Charge press conferences, and nice-sounding rehashes of the same failed, cruel policies of austerity and precarity.
Our guest is The Wren Collective's Henna Khan.
*
Guest
Henna Khan is a criminal defense attorney, litigator and now an advisor at The Wren Collective. She previously served as a staff attorney for the Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem.
**
Show Notes
Adam Johnson | March 4, 2022 | The Column
Mayor Eric Adams Delivers Address on Mental Health Crisis in New York City and Holds Q-and-A
Eric Adams | November 29, 2022 | The City of New York
Media’s Crime Hype and Scapegoating Led to Crackdown on Unhoused People
Julie Hollar | December 7, 2022 | FAIR
Adams’ Forced Hospitalization Plan Will Have Lifelong Consequences
Jerry Iannelli | December 7, 2022 | The Appeal
Statement | December 9, 2022 | CIR/SEIU
NYC Mayor Eric Adams's terrible plan to forcibly hospitalize homeless people with mental illness
Bob Hennelly | December 13, 2022 | Salon
Patients familiar with NYC mental health system skeptical of new Adams policy
Bahar Ostadan | December 14, 2022 | Gothamist
Forced Treatment for Mental Illness Is No Treatment at All
Arvind Sooknanan | December 16, 2022 | Slate
Catherine Cox and Hilary Marland | May 2015 | Social History of Medicine
The Nineteenth Century British Workhouse: Mission Not Accomplished
Brenda Derin | December 2019 | Dominican University of California
The Asylum, the Workhouse, and the Voice of the Insane Poor in 19th-Century England
Peter Bartlett | February 1998 | International Journal of Law and Psychiatry
Fiona D. Xu | 2020 | Inquiries Journal: Special Editions
Oliver Twist and the workhouse
Ruth Richardson | May 15, 2014 | British Library
***
References
April 22, 2022 | CBS Sacramento
California bill would ban homeless encampments along American River Parkway
Chris Nichols | April 12, 2022 | CAP Radio / NPR
Clean up underway in homeless camp near Utah State Capitol
Spencer Joseph | April 27, 2022 | FOX13
Majority of D.C. residents support clearing of homeless encampments, Post poll finds
Kyle Swenson, Emily Guskin and Scoot Clement | February 24, 2022 | The Washington Post
Adams Plan to Remove Homeless People From the Subway ‘Right Away’ Has Hit a Delay
Greg B. Smith | February 27, 2022 | The City
New York wants to stop people from living in the subways. But where will they go?
Ryan W. Miller | Februray 21, 2022 | USA Today
***
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here.
****
Citations Merch!
The Citations Needed merch store is open! Continue to support the show by picking up a t-shirt, tank top, sweatshirt, tote or coffee mug for yourself or your favorite Citations fan.
*****
Credits
Senior Producer: Florence Barrau-Adams
Producer: Julianne Tveten
Production Assistant: Trendel Lightburn
Newsletter: Marco Cartolano
Transcription: Morgan McAslan
Music: Grandaddy
******
Comments
Jordan Scheibel
Yes, when it is removed from its actual clinical context and used broadly, which in turn cheapens its actual utility
murt pie
Which only underscores just how vacuous that rhetoric is.
CARRIERHASARRIVED
and it still sucks. its such a perfect scene im glad you guys put in an older version of it
CARRIERHASARRIVED
"Are there no prisons? No poor houses?" "But some would rather die than--" "If they're going to die, they better do it! And decrease the surplus population!"
Dash X
Hoping that Adams is visited by three ghosts tonight … not that I think it would change him, sadly.
Jordan Scheibel
The way Eric Adam’s uses the language of trauma and empathy to provide cover for fundamentally reactionary policies towards unhoused people sounds like the concept of elite capture that Olufemi Taiwo writes about. Someone like Eric Adams is the perfect vehicle for it because materially he’s a cop and real estate schill but aesthetically he can pantomime concerned liberalism.
natfos 💌
this is going to be hard for me to listen to, in the winter especially all i can do is think of the people out there just trying to stay warm. may everyone preventing human beings from being warm at night go to hell
Ciaran Colley
Merry Festivus to you, and thanks for an excellent but depressing episode to end the year. Absolutely correct re the point that 'law and order' remedies have very little to do with the law. They often have very little to do with 'order' either.