Ep. 166: The Convenient Conventional Wisdom of "Education as Great Equalizer" Appeals
🕑 Added 2022-09-14 14:31:10 +0000 UTC"Education... is a great equalizer of conditions of men—the balance wheel of the social machinery," stated school reformer Horace Mann in 1848. "Math is the great equalizer," preached Jaime Escalante, Edward James Olmos’ character, in the 1988 film Stand and Deliver. "The best anti-poverty program around is a world-class education," announced Barack Obama during his 2010 State of the Union address.
This message is everywhere, pervading political speeches, Oscar-bait films, think-tank papers, and everything in between. The key to economic upward mobility—we’re endlessly told, is education—a societal building block that is, or at least should be, accessible to every child, no matter their race, gender, or income level. It's a seductive, seemingly unassailable conceit, suggesting that we live in a meritocracy where second chances and generational wealth-building are possible, even probable, with a few simple tools.
But is there any truth to this idea? There’s a growing body of evidence showing that education level does not, in fact, necessarily translate to higher wages. Which raises the questions: Why has the idea that education is the ultimate anti-poverty tool persisted? Whose interests are served in its continuation? And who, in turn, pays the price?
On this episode, the Season Six premiere of Citations Needed, we detail and debunk the widespread conventional wisdom that education is the rising tide that lifts all boats, looking at the ways it reinforces themes of individualism and personal responsibility; obscures systemic issues like racism and worker exploitation in the labor market; and ultimately keeps people entrenched in, rather than liberating them from, poverty and low-wage work.
Our guest is Lake Forest professor Cristina Viviana Groeger.
*
Guest
Cristina Viviana Groeger (@tinagroeger) is a historian of education and work in the modern United States. An Assistant Professor in the Department of History at Lake Forest College, she is the author of The Education Trap: Schools and the Remaking of Inequality in Boston (Harvard University Press, 2021).
**
Show Notes
No, Education Still Won’t Solve Poverty
Cristina Groeger and Mike Stivers | April 14, 2021 | Jacobin
Is Education No Longer the ‘Great Equalizer’?
Thomas B. Edsall | June 23, 2021 | The New York Times
‘Turnaround is a relic’: Chicago officially winds down reform-era school improvement program
Cassie Walker Burke | May 26, 2021 | Chalkbeat Chicago
Chicago Ends Arne Duncan’s Failed Strategy of “Turnaround” and “Disruption”
Diane Ravitch | June 3, 201 | Diane Ravitch's Blog
More education doesn’t always get you more money, report finds
Jessica Dickler | October 13, 2021 | CNBC
Chris Warhurst (Ed.) | 2017 | Palgrave McMillan
The Birth of the Gap: The Historical Beginning of Achievement Gap Rhetoric
Laura Jones | 2013 | American Education Research Association
Tom Moore | January 19, 2007 | The New York Times
Report: Charters Schools Aren’t Improving Student Achievement in Chicago
Kevin Solari | October 17, 2014 | In These Times
To close the skills gap, start with the learning gap
Randa Grob-Zakhary and Jessica Hjarrand | August 3, 2017 | Brookings
U.S. Ranks 23rd Out of 30 Developed Countries for Inequality
Gillian B. White | January 16, 2017 | The Atlantic
The Incorporation of America: Culture and Society in the Gilded Age
Alan Trachtenberg | 1982 | Hill and Wang
Standing at Armageddon: The United States, 1877-1919
Nell Irvin Painter | 1989 | W.W. Norton
***
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here.
****
Citations Merch!
Don't forget, the Citations Needed merch store is now open! Continue to support the show by picking up a t-shirt, tank top, sweatshirt, tote or coffee mug for yourself or your favorite Citations fan.
*****
Credits
Senior Producer: Florence Barrau-Adams
Producer: Julianne Tveten
Production Assistant: Trendel Lightburn
Newsletter: Marco Cartolano
Transcription: Morgan McAslan
Music: Grandaddy
******
Comments
Dash X
Another great segment.
Havo
I have "Lean On Me" on in the background and holy shit does it have some problematic politics. The movie opens with a prestine HS and a class of bright lily white students in a civics class. Morgan Freeman quits and it turns into a hell hole with a majority black and brown student body. Jesus Christ.
Ciaran Colley
Welcome back, and a fantastic episode. Unfortunately, the 'Stand and Deliver' reference made me think immediately of the parody in South Park.
Danny Cozzi
Been meaning to subscribe here for a bit, but this episode blew me away. Excellent research and presentation as always. Welcome back!
Cécile Choplin
Welcome back!! Hope we'll get an episode addressing the tough on crime notions on some left wing media as well soon in the future. And I don't just mean The Young Turks but Jacobin & the Ben Burgis types have towed a very similar line. Would love to hear a detailed episode from you guys about that
Major Major
Hope you all had a restful vacation.
V K
Yay, new season. Also, very happy to see you stand by your principles against those on the left who push carceral politics.
David
Glad to have you guys back also first