FapsCommunity
citationsneededpodcast from patreon
citationsneededpodcast patreon

Newsletter 2.15.22

🕑 Added 2022-02-15 17:07:45 +0000 UTC

Comments

Caleb Evenson

That makes sense. I agree with you despite thinking people should not hang so much on headlines.

Dash X

I suspect that is correct, without knowing for sure, which is why I suggested only a clarification. The title could easily have been clarified. As it stands, the title literally states that "defenses" -- not certain defenses, not some defenses, not "right-wing media" defenses, but "defenses" -- of Joe Rogan are NOT about free speech. And the title further declares that they ARE "right-wing solidarity." I completely get why some people are put off by that, including some Citations Needed listeners if you read the comments. And it seems like an unnecessary confusion, if we are correct about the intention, that is easily fixed with a simple "tweak" or two. That is all I was getting at. Didn't intend to inflame controversy.

Caleb Evenson

If the title was meant to summarize the article, then it would follow that "Defenses" indeed refers to the right-wing outlets Ari Paul quoted and criticized. Of course, one can write a headline with different intentions, but considering it came from FAIR, I don't think whoever wrote the headline was trying to smear everybody who sincerely attempts defending Rogan on the basis of free speech rights.

Dash X

No. Of course I didn't "unsub" over the article. The title of the article makes it seem to me, and apparently a few people who commented there, that any defense of Rogan is necessarily "right wing solidarity." I think that is wrong. If, as some in the comments there suggest, Ari was targeting his article only at "right wing" outlets who came to defend Rogan, okay. But the title reads more broadly than that.

Belladonna Rose

From the title it's clear the defenses in question are the ones about free speech and the whole spotify hubbub, and that matches exactly with the article. EDIT: lmao did you unsub as a patreon over this article?

Dash X

Ari Paul's article for FAIR (linked above) really needs a tweak or two. Clarification in the title would help. There are a lot of thoughtful comments under the article taking issue with the notion that any defense of Rogan is "right-wing solidarity." It is tough to avoid that conclusion taking the contents of the article together with its title. Some have suggested that Paul did not mean it that way, and that the title is misleading. If that is the case, it should be clarified. As it stands, it seems kind of messed up.


More Creators