FapsCommunity
citationsneededpodcast from patreon
citationsneededpodcast patreon

Ep. 154: The Problem with “Inclusive Patriotism” - How Radicals Are Retconned into Liberal Champions of the American Project

🕑 Added 2022-02-09 20:17:20 +0000 UTC
Ep. 154: The Problem with “Inclusive Patriotism” - How Radicals Are Retconned into Liberal Champions of the American Project

Comments

Citations Needed

I think politicians are bound by a different intellectual arrangement than writers, journalists and historians and I think it's a bit dubious to ask them to take a dump on the American flag. Once one has conceded the premise of engaging in bourgeois democracy it's weird to expect this same person to effectively reject the foundations of that system. Like asking the CFO of JP Morgan be a marxist, kind of a silly premise.

absoluteboi

the santa clause myth is the white washing of slave labor

Isadore Nabi

Great episode. I learned a bunch of CPB / NPR history that I should've already known. I expect this kind of liberal chauvinist Americana from those outlets, but what I've found more striking lately is that you're hearing it from the likes of Matt Stoller, Corbin Trent, and other ostensibly left-leaning pundits who argue the Left needs to "reclaim patriotism". I find these arguments smarmy and this episode helped me articulate why (beyond the fact that their proponents often overlap with the "populist"-to-alt-right puke funnel). That said, there was a similar argument about the Bernie 2020 campaign, that he should have drawn more heavily from our homegrown history of social-democratic policies and less from those exotic European countries. I'm more sympathetic to this version, and I don't think it necessarily implies jingoism or erases the movements that brought about those reforms -- at least not the way Bernie would tell it. Do you think there is a way to thread this needle rhetorically that could actually benefit the US Left?


More Creators