Ep. 139: Of Meat and Men - How Beef Became Synonymous with Settler-Colonial Domination
🕑 Added 2021-06-30 15:50:16 +0000 UTC"Beef. It’s what’s for dinner," the baritone voices of actors Robert Mitchum and Sam Elliott told us in the 1990s. "We’re not gonna let Joe Biden and Kamala Harris cut America’s meat!" cried Mike Pence during a speech in Iowa last year. "To meet the Biden Green New Deal targets, America has to, get this, America has to stop eating meat," lamented Donald Trump adviser Larry Kudlow on Fox Business. Repeatedly, we’re reminded that red meat is the lifeblood of American culture, a hallmark of masculine power.
This association has lingered for well over a century. Starting in the late 1800s ,as white settlers expropriated Indigenous land killing Native people and wildlife in pursuit of westward expansion across North America, the development and promotion of cattle ranching — and its product: meat — was purposefully imbued with the symbolism of dominance, aggression, and of course, manliness.
There’s an associated animating force behind this messaging as well: the perception of waning masculinity in our settler-colonial society. Whether a reaction to the closure of the American West as a tameable frontier in the late 19th century or to the contemporary Right's imagined threats of "soy boys" and a U.S. military that has supposedly gone soft under liberal command, the need to affirm a cowboy sense of manliness, defined and expressed through violence and domination, continues to take the form of consuming meat.
On this episode, we study the origins of the cultural link between meat eating and masculinity in settler-colonial North America; how this has persisted into the present day via right-wing charlatans like Jordan Peterson, Josh Hawley and Tucker Carlson who panic over the decline of masculinity; and the social and political costs of the maintenance and preservation of Western notions of manliness.
Our guest is history professor and author Kristin Hoganson.
***
Guest
Dr. Kristin L. Hoganson is a Professor of History at the University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. She is the author of books including American Empire at the Turn of the Twentieth Century, Fighting for American Manhood: How Gender Politics Provoked the Spanish-American and Philippine-American Wars and, most recently, The Heartland: An American History.
****
Show Notes
Red Meat Republic: A Hoof-To-Table History of How Beef Changed America
Joshua Specht | 2019 | Princeton University Press
Changing ideal of manhood in late-nineteenth century America
John Robert Van Slyke | 2001 | The University of Montana
Rough Rider in the White House: Theodore Roosevelt and the Politics of Desire
Sarah Watts | 2003 | University of Chicago Press
How Teddy Roosevelt Crafted an Image of American Manliness
David Roos | July 6, 2018 | The History Channel
The dubious masculinity of grilling
Rebecca Jennings | June 28, 2019 | Vox
How steak became manly and salads became feminine
Paul Freedman | October 24, 2019 | The Conversation
Kat Kinsman | February 16, 2021 | Food & Wine
Beef Is Back for Dinner as Marketers Woo Nostalgic Millennials
Alexandra Bruell | October 5, 2017 | The Wall Street Journal
Jordan Peterson, Custodian of the Patriarchy
Nellie Bowles | May 18, 2018 | The New York Times
Why I vote ‘Hell, no!’ on a vegan president
Steve Cuozzo | August 13, 2019 | The New York Post
Zachary A. Kramer | 2011 | Washington University Law Review
Why are we programmed to think meat is for men?
Laura Brehaut | June 22, 2018 | National Post
*****
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here.
******
Comments
sparky?
Melnorme
You touch on it, but the material connection is downplayed a bit I think. For instance, your guest references how in wartime meat is prioritized to men in service, and this is ascribed to value judgment. Isn't whether or not to divert the means to build muscle to people who need muscles to win a war more of a practical, material question, and not a question of who has more abstract value in society?
Citations Needed
We mention this!
Melnorme
Okay just one point: meat is associated with muscles because it is a primary source of protein, which happens to be what muscles are made out of. The guest portrays this as a psychological phenomenon. The control of meat as a source of strength is not metaphorical. It is a real, material thing that plays directly into one people's ability to literally physically overcome another, by denying the means to acquire the physical strength, the muscles, to resist.
Almost asked in the AMA if y'all were going do to this story that you teased months ago 😂. As a vegan living in Montana it's extremely appreciated
Dee Rubes
Great and important episode! My diss research was on cultures of meat production and how it influences environmental policy
Ciaran Colley
Great episode. I had no idea what you were possibly going to do with this topic, but it was incredibly interesting. Well worth my measly $5 a month!
Nic Sage, Freelance Nemesis
Great episode, though Dr. Hoganson's comment about being not aware of the term "soy boy" seemed strange. Though in fairness, they do specialize in 19th and early 20th century politics. Just caught me off-guard.
so excited for this! people really don’t talk or think about this narrative enough. thank you guys
Excited to see this one. My father is a Jordan Peterson loyalist and has taken to the "Carnivore" diet as a result.