Ep. 131: The "Essential Worker" Racket - How 'COVID Hero' Discourse Is Used To Discipline Labor
🕑 Added 2021-02-17 15:10:12 +0000 UTC"Elon Musk sent a thank-you note to Tesla's workers returning to work," Business Insider squeals. Walmart teams up with UPS to air an ad "thanking essential workers." "Jeff Bezos Just Posted an Open Letter to Amazon Employees About the Coronavirus. Every Smart Business Leader Needs to Read It," insists an article in Inc.
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, corporate leaders, politicians and celebrities have been quick to paint "essential workers," and those often described as "frontline" workers, as heroes — laborers conscripted, presumably against their will, into a wartime-like scenario of heroism and sacrifice as our country battles the ongoing coronavirus scourge.
The sentiment behind this rhetoric is understandable, especially from everyday people simply trying to express their deep appreciation for the underpaid labor doing the work to feed, house, care for and treat everyone else. But when deployed by powerful politicians and CEOs, the "essential workers as heroes" discourse serves a more sinister purpose: to curb efforts to unionize, preemptively justify mass death of a largely black and brown workforce, protect corporate profits and ultimately discipline labor that for a brief moment in spring of last year, had unprecedented leverage to extract concessions from capital.
As Wall Street booms and America’s billionaires see an increase of $1.1 trillion in wealth since March 2020 — a 40% increase — while the average worker suffers from unemployment, depression, drug abuse and a loss of healthcare, it’s become increasingly clear that “essential” never meant essential to helping society at large or essential to human care or essential to keeping the bottom from falling out, but essential to keeping the top one percent of the one percent’s wealth and power intact and as it turned out to be the case, massively expanded.
Indeed, 2020 saw the largest transfer of wealth from the poor to the rich in decades, a transfer largely made possible by the essential worker as hero narrative, with little discussion or debate. In March 2020 everyone agreed in this wartime framing that was going to send off millions of poor people to their deaths for a vague, undecided greater good of the quote-unquote "economy," when really it was for the seamless maintenance of Wall Street profits.
On this episode, we explore the origins of the concept of "essential work" and those deemed "essential workers"; how it's been used in the past to discipline labor during wartime; how hero narratives provide an empty, head-patting verbal tip in lieu of worker protection and higher pay; and why so few in our media ask the more urgent question of all: whether or not low wage retail, food, farming, and healthcare workers ever wanted to be heroes in the first place.
Our guest in Ronald Jackson of Warehouse Workers For Justice.
***
Guest
Ronald Jackson is a worker and organizer at Warehouse Workers For Justice.
****
Show Notes
Hollis Johnson | November 1, 2020 | Business Insider
The “Essential Worker” Swindle
Sarah Lazare | January 22, 2021 | In These Times
Amazon and Walmart Halted Hazard Pay For Workers Despite Making $30 Billion
Rick Claypool | November 25, 2020 | Public Citizen
Hamilton Nolan | March 24, 2020 | In These Times
Leaked Amazon Memo Details Plan to Smear Fired Warehouse Organizer: ‘He’s Not Smart or Articulate’
Paul Blest | April 2, 2020 | VICE
The Plan Is to Save Capital and Let the People Die
Hamilton Nolan | April 6, 2020 | In These Times
9 Amazon Workers Describe the Daily Risks They Face in the Pandemic
Louise Matsakis | April 10, 2020 | WIRED
The WWE Is Now Considered an ‘Essential Service’ in Florida
Mihir Zaveri | April 14, 2020 | The New York Times
Walmart & Uber’s TV Ads Praise Frontline Heroes. But How Much Are Companies Helping?
Harmon Leon | | May 1, 2020 | Observer
Target, Walmart workers and others plan 'sickout' protests over coronavirus safety
Erik Ortiz | May 1, 2020 | NBC News
Who are essential workers? A comprehensive look at their wages, demographics, and unionization rates
Celine McNicholas and Margaret Poydock | May 19, 2020 | Economic Policy Institute
Striking Essential Workers Are Today’s Human Rights Defenders
Frank Kearl, Cecilia Chang and Matthew Burnett | May 1, 2020 | Justice Initiative
Wealth of US billionaires rises by nearly a third during pandemic
Rupert Neate | September 17, 2020 | The Guardian
Billionaire Wealth vs. Community Health: Protecting Essential Workers from Pandemic Profiteers
Bianca Agustin, Chuck Collins, Jonathan Heller, Sara Myklebust and Omar Ocampo | November 2020 | Institute of Policy Studies
Secret Amazon Reports Expose the Company’s Surveillance of Labor and Environmental Groups
Lauren Kaori Gurley | November 23, 2020 | VICE
Amazon to face federal lawsuit over firing of warehouse worker
Zoe Schiffer | December 4, 2020 | The Verge
Molly Kinder and Laura Stateler | December 22, 2020 | Brookings
*****
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here.
******
Comments
Great episode. Really love that you give a platform to workers that are rarely heard from despite being front and center in this crisis. Also can I request a news brief with Ronald’s extended review of Suicide Squad?
Elon Musk is a real piece of ****.. back when covid first shut everything down, Elon musk held his workers hostage over the reopening of the Tesla factory. The event goes: Local government of Alameda county shut down all know essential work industry like Tesla’s factory. To my only guess Tesla must be in a mountain of debt where a slightest touch of a feather could bankrupt the company, as to why it works vigorously hard and even breaks hand full of labor laws (they were charged for breaking 12 labor laws in 2018 and found guilty but suffered 0 consequences) to prevent Unionizing of their workers. So Elon forces the doors open, forces his workers to work by doing this: despite local law saying the factory is closed, he reopens and said (which is all documented in his stupid twitter posts) that if Alameda county fights him on this, he will move his factory out of CA and to Texas.. Look at this from the perspective of Alameda local gov.. option 1: you force your regulations not allowing the factory to open.. elon musk takes tesla and moves out of the state and all of a sudden 10,000!! Employees lose their jobs and everyone hates the local government not elon because of media manipulation... option 2: despite your local regulations, let elon spit and walk all over them, he reopens the factory you do nothing about it, further adding to the fact local gov holds no power over its community furthering the talking point that gov is a joke.. its a lose lose for the community and the local government but of course you are going to pick option 2 because the last thing local government in the US wants is 10,000 angry jobless local workers on your doorstep... So this is a classic 101 Corporation using workers as a hostage bargaining chips against government to get there way which further adds to my conclusion (government is a state and the state is a tool used by the capitalist class to enforce their legitimacy and rule) Winners capitalists and scum of the earth elon who continued to threaten the closure of Tesla in CA giving 10,000 workers anxiety and stress through a ****ing pandemic too this very day... Losers: all of us, the entirety of working class Americans every god damn day of the week :(
Teresa Elam
Listening to those quotes from the CEOs was genuinely nauseating....
No Borders Only Podcasts
Nima! Adam! I'll listen to this episode tonight (or tomorrow) but I've terrible news: There was a whole segment on trade jobs with Mike Rowe on the PBS Newshour tonight. Another sign that PBS is being pulled ever more rightward. (I mean, there's a good point to be made that there's classism against trade jobs, but that's not the real intention of the segment. No one even asked why college costs so much when they talked about the high costs of college). My apologies for not commenting on the current CN episode. But seeing Mike Rowe on PBS was shocking (and it's not even a debate! He's the only "expert" they interview). I wouldn't known who he was, though, had it not been for that earlier CN episode.
Great episode!!! In less extreme times, this reminds of those business articles that occasionally make it to MSM that extol the virtues of treating workers well IN LIEU OF more pay. No, we deserve BOTH humane treatment AND a living wage you soulless mofos.
Jean
I'm very excited to listen to this episode! Can't wait to rage against the corporate skeeves along with you