Ep. 124 - Mental Health During A Pandemic: How US Media Spins Societal Failures Into Personal Self-Help Journeys
🕑 Added 2020-11-25 19:11:38 +0000 UTCA CNN headline from this past summer read: “Mental health during coronavirus: Tips for processing your feelings.” Psychology Today gave us an article on “Coping With Loneliness During a Pandemic,” while the Washington Post presents, “A guide to taking care of yourself during the pandemic.” Everywhere we’ve turned over the past 9 months, American media has been covering the mental health downside of the COVID-19 pandemic and the subsequent lockdown and economic crash on one of these two settings: Awareness Mode or Self-Help Mode.
The first setting — “Awareness Mode” — is merely witnessing mass suffering; that is, reporting on the topic with no prescriptions offered. Second is “Self-Help Mode,” which is, to the extent these articles do put forth prescriptions for wellness and mental health, it is entirely individualistic in nature. Your well-being during this once-in-a-century pandemic is up to you — but don’t fret, here are some “guides,” ”plans,” “hacks,” and “tricks” to help you out.
Missing from the vast bulk of coverage is the glaringly obvious third option: actionable, proven, political solutions to mental health crises that operate under the radical assumption that social problems may require social solutions. Nowhere in any of these articles is the idea that socialized medicine, guaranteed income, free childcare, student debt relief or rent and mortgage cancellations may be the best and most rational “hacks” or “tricks” to actually improve mental health of people at scale.
Obviously, a robust social safety net wouldn’t solve all mental health problems — after all, countries with universal healthcare and generous unemployment and childcare benefits still have depression and suicides — but we have decades of data showing basic social welfare clearly improves mental welfare. But because mental health crises are seen as moral failings rather than diseases thrust upon innocent people, we are conditioned to view those suffering from their effects as inevitable, losses simply factored into the moral framework of the world.
It basically goes like this: If a giant blood-sucking monster were ravaging the country killing thousands of people and terrorizing millions more, the media would never provide us “hacks” or “plans” or “tricks” to cope with the giant blood-sucking monster. It would ask the obvious question: What are those in power doing to stop the monster from killing and terrorizing in the first place?
Unfortunately, such an approach is sacrilege in U.S. media when it comes to mental health. The solution is never to lobby for a specific candidate or policy that would provide immediate relief to the masses because neoliberal hyper-atomization, unlike appeals to social solutions, is not seen as political. It’s simply the objective reporter voice mode of journalism U.S. media has uncritically adopted. But collectivist solutions, marked by the political choice to redistribute resources to the less well-off, is a proven technique to help those suffering mental health issues, doubly so during a pandemic that has cut people off from socialization, radially increased substance abuse, and has left millions unemployed.
Our guest is writer Colette Shade.
***
Guest
Colette Shade is an essayist and Masters student at the University of Maryland School of Social Work, where she focuses on behavioral health and psychotherapy. Her writing has appeared in publications including The New Republic, Current Affairs, Jacobin, and The Baffler, and she is currently working on a book about the political causes of mental illness. Follow her @MsShade.
****
Show Notes
Self-Help Hacks at the End of the World
Colette Shade | October 19, 2020 | The New Republic
The GOP Is Exploiting Fears of Rising Suicides to Protect Wall Street Profits
Sarah Lazare | March 26, 2020 | In These Times
During pandemic, growth of U.S. adults with mental health issues jumps to 53 percent
Linda Searing | September 6, 2020 | The Washington Post
Pandemic depression is about to collide with seasonal depression. Make a plan, experts say.
Chelsea Cirruzzo | October 27, 2020 | The Washington Post
How Will We Cope With the Pandemic Fall?
Jeff Wilser | October 9, 2020 | The New York Times
The Pandemic Is a ‘Mental Health Crisis’ for Parents
Jessica Grose | September 9, 2020 | The New York Times
The Impossible Math of the Pandemic
J.C. Pan | July 7, 2020 | The New Republic
CDC: One quarter of young adults contemplated suicide during pandemic
Brianna Ehley | August 13, 2020 | Politico
CDC study sheds new light on mental health crisis linked to coronavirus pandemic
Jacqueline Howard & Andrea Kane | August 13, 2020 | CNN
The Implications of COVID-19 for Mental Health and Substance Use
Nirmita Panchal et al. | August 21, 2020 | Kaiser Family Foundation
Coping With Loneliness During a Pandemic
Lisa Firestone | April 20, 2020 | Psychology Today
Stan Dorn | July 13, 2020 | FamiliesUSA
Simone Rambotti | February 2020 | Social Science & Medicine
Paid family leave is an investment in public health, not a handout
Darby Saxbe | February 20, 2019 | The Conversation
Using Social Determinants of Health Data to Improve Health Care and Health: A Learning Report
L. DeMilto & M. Nakashian | May 2, 2016 | Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
Social Determinants of Mental Health
World Health Organization & Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation | 2014
*****
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here.
******
Comments
Hex Witch Circe
Thanks, I may give this a look.
Citations Needed
It was somewhat inarticulately put, I explain my point in much greater detail on this podcast that expressed similar objections to what I said https://shittychristians.podbean.com/
Hex Witch Circe
Overall a very good episode. However, I think that claiming that all spirituality and religion is intrinsically anti-leftist is wildly ahistorical and very narrowly focused on a specific type of religion that has cultivated an individualistic sin-obsessed and anti-worldly ideology, which is very far from being true of all religion. Kinda disappointed, Citations Needed has really set a standard of having more measured and thoughtful takes than this.
Chachalupa
This popped up while I was listening to the episode https://apple.news/AM9qfs8RFRGOHP5eKMsM-6A
Citations Needed
Thank you so much for sharing this.
I am so grateful that you all did this episode. One of my closest friends took her own life earlier this month and it bothered me so much that people kept saying over and over "check in on your friends." I checked in on her. Everyone close to her did. She still died. Thankfully we have an incredible student newspaper here in Albuquerque, which published a story I helped write about why neoliberal individualistic solutions are not enough: https://www.dailylobo.com/article/2020/11/structural-changes-needed-to-prevent-tragic-deaths-like-kunm-news-director
Citations Needed
Thank you for this! Yes it’s definitely a rich topic, if you ever write anything on it let us know we’d be happy to share.
Thank you guys SO MUCH for doing this episode. I am a therapist and I am constantly frustrated by how the media, the medical industrial complex, and people with political power constantly remove all social and political context from the problem of "mental illness." One critique that I am going to offer is about the use of the terms "mental illness" and "mental disorder" in and of themselves. As a mental health professional, I avoid using these terms whenever possible, because I believe that even those terms contribute to the individualization and the depoliticization of mental health. A person who is depressed and/or anxious because they cannot pay their rent (or due to other societal circumstances) does not have a disorder. Their brain and body are functioning exactly as they were designed to function. We pump out cortisol (the stress hormone) when our 'fight or flight' response kicks in because this is a survival mechanism. OF COURSE you are in survival mode when you cannot pay your rent. We produce dopamine (the happy hormone) when we do things that we like doing. OF COURSE you do not have the time and space to do things you enjoy doing when you are worrying about paying rent/getting evicted. A person who is depressed (even to the point of suicidality) or anxious because of circumstances which were caused by greater society DOES NOT have a disorder or an illness. It is the larger SOCIETY that has the disorder. When I talk to my clients and explain their "symptoms" (another word I don't like) using this framework, they start to feel more empowered, less alienated, and less self critical. Because at the very least they know that the way they feel is not their fault. I respect you guys tremendously for tackling this topic and I hope that this episode has some "spiritual sequels" coming in the future because there is SO MUCH more to say
Sparrowhawk
I now want to see a satirical movie or TV show where the earth has been invaded by monsters and all we get are life-hack tips on how to not get eaten. Although to be honest...I'm afraid such a satire might not be far from what could actually happen.