News Brief: Sorkin's "Chicago 7" Retcons 1960's Radicals as Boring Liberals in GOTV Thriller
🕑 Added 2020-10-19 01:31:04 +0000 UTCIn this Patreon News Brief, we discuss the new Netflix film "The Trial of the Chicago 7" which continues Hollywood's storied tradition of stripping the 1960s of its romantic, radical ideas and reducing it to one-off political preferences, aesthetics, and oedipal neurosis.
Comments
Juliet Saxton
The way Sorkin sort of evaded Bobby seale is so frustrating because Seize the Time is so interesting and his perspective and experience was so deep. His time in jail with Jerry Rubin could have been a better duo than Rubin/Hoffman in my opinion.
The sort of deference to process and the "getting better people in there" sort of mentality reminds me serial season 3 and nice white parents, serial productions new podcast. Both portray incredibly unsettling phenomena with clarity but then at the end they just sort of say "well maybe the people should be nicer"
Ciaran Colley
Thanks guys, now I'm definitely going to watch it! "Bobby, don't go to Chicago - we gotta phonebank for Hubert Humphrey!" There has been a misconception that though the politics of his oeuvre is and has been abominable, nevertheless Sorkin is a good writer. However, he seems to adopt a 'tell, don't show' attitude to writing drama, and as has been pointed out frequently on The West Wing Thing podcast, there is only one character in an Aaron Sorkin work: Aaron Sorkin. He does seem to have a knack for producing compelling dramas, but that's a matter of pacing rather than intricate plotting - that's why it's possible to binge-watch The West Wing and sit right the way through something like Charlie Wilson's War. It's a series of expensive sets, prestigious casts and rat-a-tat-tat dialogue designed to hook you and yet distract you from the ongoing plotholes, dreadful characterisation, authorial grandstanding and, of course, the rampant misogyny/racism. He's the screenwriting equivalent of Tomacco. I suggest checking out a Mitchell and Webb sketch involving a pair of lazy TV writers who produced a legal drama called 'Speedo'. It has all the hallmarks of a Sorkin badass lawyer series!
Eli
Love that you guys mention how Sorkin plagiarizes himself. He's not the only writer to do that of course. But he's easily the most egregious offender.
Ryan
I found the movie very entertaining and enjoyable. But I am a simpleton. Came here to see why. I don't think the movie deserves hate but absolutely agreed with the assessments and how the movie never said one anti capitalists thing through the whole movie. I still think it can be used as a talking point with friends and even a bridge to leftist views.
Citations Needed
Very generous reading!
Just a little “um actually” for ya, I thought Seale was referring to Bobby Hutton, not Kennedy
Sam Humleker
Is it too much to hope for that you guys will suffer through the West Wing special for our listening pleasure?
Thanks for this review. Another awful moment: when Sorkin makes it the Prosecutor’s idea to give Bobby Seale a mistrial.... In reality it was the defense attorney.