Episode 116: The Pro-Gentrification Aspirationalism of HGTV's House-Flipping Shows
🕑 Added 2020-07-29 15:28:05 +0000 UTCThe popularity of HGTV house-flipping TV shows can’t be overstated: In the second week of July, HGTV was the fourth highest rated cable network, behind only Fox News, MSNBC and CNN, making it the highest rated entertainment network in the United States. Its most prominent programming: the reliable, risk free formula of home flipping shows. All of these shows—Flip or Flop and its many regional spinoffs, Good Bones, Flipping 101, to name just a few—share a basic formula: house-flippers, usually a family business in the form of a husband and wife team or parent and child with a folksy rapport, buy a neglected house on the cheap—cue zoom-ins on mold, water damage, decaying wood, dust and dead bugs—that’s often in a relatively poor or gentrifying neighborhood.
They then turn it into something they describe as "beautiful", to be sold at a much higher price to, most likely, young white people looking for a "funky" home in an "up-and-coming" neighborhood. But at what cost do these glossy, get-rich-quick reality shows entertain us? What ideologies do they promote, and how do they erase the working class black and brown families whose housing was condemned, and communities were systemically neglected, before the camera’s even began rolling?
On this episode—our Season 3 finale—we take a look at these shows to understand how and why HGTV became a glorified commercial for house-flipping and gentrification, examining its indifference to housing instability and its dead-eyed cheerleading of “middle-class” bourgeois aspirationalism, no matter the social cost.
Our guests are culture writer Ann-Derrick Gaillot and Atlanta-based community organizer Kamau Franklin.
***
Guests
Ann-Derrick Gaillot is a culture writer and reporter based in Montana. Her work has appeared in Bustle, Rolling Stone, The Nation, The Fader, Pitchfork, The Outline, and other publications. Follow her @AnnDerrickG.
Kamau Franklin is a community organizer, attorney and founder and Board president of Community Movement Builders, Inc. in Atlanta, Georgia. Follow him @kamaufranklin.
****
Show Notes
Ann-Derrick Gaillot | June 6, 2017 | The Outline
An Inside Look at How HGTV Became an Industry Juggernaut
Dante A. Ciampaglia | July 29, 2019 | Architectural Digest
Caitlin Flanagan | September 20, 2017 | Vulture
HGTV Will Never Upset You: How the Network Beat CNN in 2016
Gerry Smith | December 28, 2016 | Bloomberg
Banks Should Face History and Pay Reparations
Angela Glover Blackwell and Michael McAfee | June 26, 2020 | The New York Times
Renters, homeowners face new phase of coronavirus crisis with evictions, foreclosures looming
Alexis Keenan | July 10, 2020 | Yahoo Finance
Big Texas cities are rapidly gentrifying, but none as fast as Houston
Andy Olin | January 8, 2020 | Rice Kinder Institute for Urban Research
Breonna Taylor warrant connected to Louisville gentrification plan, lawyers say
Phillip M. Bailey and Tessa Duvall | July 5, 2020 | Louisville Courier Journal
Bernie Sanders proposes a 25 percent 'House Flipping tax' in new housing plan
Tim O'Donnell | September 18, 2019 | The Week
Chicago Residents Are Upset With Alison Victoria From 'Windy City Rehab' — Here's Why
Jessie Quinn | February 8, 2019 | Cheatsheet
Work stopped at ‘Windy City Rehab’ properties as HGTV stars face discipline by city
Tracy Swartz | July 10, 2019 | Chicago Tribune
A Decade After The Bubble Burst, House Flipping Is On The Rise
All Things Considered | April 17, 2018 | NPR/WNYC
NYC House Flipping Is On The Rise, Exacerbating Gentrification
Lylla Younes | May 30, 2018 | Gothamist
How Redlining’s Racist Effects Lasted for Decades
Emily Badger | August 24, 2017 |The New York Times
How Homeownership Became the Engine of American Inequality
Matthew Desmond | May 9, 2017 |The New York Times
Catherine Jheon | May 29, 2017 | Toronto Life
Millions of Renters Face Eviction—Why Today’s Housing Market is Partially to Blame
Taylor Marr | December 12, 2016 | Redfin
Redlining’s Legacy Of Inequality: Low Homeownership Rates, Less Equity For Black Households
Brenda Richardson | June 11, 2020 | Forbes
Black Homeownership Drops to All-Time Low
Laura Kusisto | July 15, 2019 | The Wall Street Journal
Black homeownership is as low as it was when housing discrimination was legal
Michelle Singletary | April 5, 2018 | The Washington Post
Homeownership Rate in the U.S. Drops to Lowest Since 1965
Prashant Gopal | July 28, 2016 | Bloomberg
*****
Transcript
For a full transcript of this episode, go here.
******
Comments
Ryan Stempien
I think a lot of the gentrification narrative really misses the mark. You guys do a great job of detailing the negative impacts of gentrification, and I'm not saying there aren't negative impacts .. but I think if you look at a lot of the problems in the country today, a lot of them can be traced back to the fact that we've forgotten how to live WITH each other. One of the strongest indicators as to whether a child will be employed in adulthood is how many of their neighbors were employed, so shouldn't we WANT comparatively rich people to move into comparatively poorer neighborhoods? More importantly though, and you guys touch on this in your last episode, but the VAST majority of urban areas are not experiencing gentrification - instead they're facing divestment and decline. I think we in the bourgeoisie focus a lot on gentrification because it's the thing happening in the urban neighborhoods WE live in, but in reality it's not the biggest problem in our cities today. The biggest problems are in the neighborhoods facing divestment, depopulation, and decline. Focusing on the gentrifying neighborhoods happens at the cost of focusing on neighborhoods which have been getting poorer and more desperate for at least the last 50 years. None of this is to say I disliked the episode, or don't think you guys made some really strong points, I just think that gentrification really isn't what those of us who care about decreasing suffering in urban spaces should put too much of our energy into combating. I think we should work to ameliorate the negative side effects of gentrification (annoyingly referred to as "gentlefication"), but in general should look to "gentrify" more urban areas. You guys ask "what does "turning the corner" actually mean" .. well areas, post gentrification will have higher levels of public services, better infrastructure, better schools, homeowners will find it easier to maintain their house with access to HELOCs because their home's value isn't decreasing, etc. As long as we can find a way to help long term residents share in that prosperity, I think we should work to make that process play out in as many neighborhoods as possible.
Matt
Right, which of course helps drive down "labor costs" (ie, your pay) as well.
Zach
How about the pricing on these shows? It always seems to be 'at cost' or something because I don't think you will find many contractors to do the work at the prices they list
Matt
EXCELLENT episode, guys. As a former construction worker, the part about who actually does the labor in all this really resonated. Also, we used to complain about how HGTV gave some nightmare clients pretty unrealistic expectations about how quickly the project would get done, and they'd make all these insane requests for changes at the last minute. So yeah! good stuff. Also from the gentrification angle.
Havo
Umm, actually, Adam, Cameron Poe was an Army Ranger, not a Marine. Do better.
Marti Abernathey
I have a couple of problems with the episode. First off, Indianapolis is where I was born and spent the first 40 years of my life. You make this a truly black and white issue, but did you discuss the "white flight" from the downtown area to the South and North? `Did you discuss the condition of the heavily segregated nature of the city and how that impacts schools or public health? How this segregation impacts things like food deserts and property tax (that impacts school funding)? I get that total gentrification of areas are a bad thing that pushes people out. But that isn't the case in places like Fountain Square or on the Near East side of Indianapolis. Bringing more money into the these neighborhoods, pull up property values for the people that already own and live there. I mean capitalism sucks, but this show seemed to be pretty lopsided (at least from the POV of someone that lived and worked in Indianapolis).
Sydney Shuster
Thanks for another great season! Your full team is amazing :) But also, you should take a REAL summer break. A month doesn’t seem long enough haha
Ciaran Colley
To think that all this time, I've been paying a Patreon subscription like a fool, when I could have invested in a crackhouse! Have a great rest of the summer folks, and I look forward to season 4.
Tom Kelly
17:48 Gonna be that guy... it wasn't Springfield being renovated, it was in a promo vid for an upstate company town called Cypress Creek (that Homer was invited to move to for a new job) where such mailbox-ification happened. (The Simpsons is one of the few TV shows I actually love and defend. I don't get to do this often.) Otherwise this episode is good eating for me as I have landlord problems myself rn, as I imagine most of us do. Abolish landlords and gentrification already. Top season guys, cheers ✌
Great episode! Now I guess ill just sit in silence till season 4....
SamT
Thank you guys,! Great season and finale Cheers
Potato
Awesome episode, only halfway throw but great points so far. Only issue: it’s Lou-uh-vull, not Louise-Ville
thank you!
David T Hollis
oh HELL yes
Potato
Lol that was fast, at least the medium linked work to get to SoundCloud.