davidfirth patreon

A question about Patreon

🕑 Added 2017-05-29 01:26:22 +0000 UTC

Comments

Will Davenport

I heard you say in an interview you made some 20 minute long cartoons when you were just starting out, do you think those will make it onto this site at some point? I'm sure we'd all love to see them

Robbie Cumming

Oh, yeah I can imagine, they'd do anything for the traffic. Anyway, I'm glad you're doing Patreon, I've followed your work since the very beginning so it's great to now be involved in a tiny way.

David Firth

I will do that in the future but with Cream I didn't want sneaky blogs to post it out before my official release and get all the traffic. That tends to happen.

Robbie Cumming

Hi David, I usually just publish my videos just to Youtube but as unlisted for about 12 hours before releasing to the general pubelicks. I know that probably doesn't help at all but might be of interest!

Bester

Good spot though, I didn't think of that.

Dan Alsop

Two ideas: 1. Forget the Vimeo version. Just do YouTube, but keep the video as "Unlisted" for a couple of days. If those that have paid for EA share they're shooting themselves in the foot. Then you can keep the same URL in the Patreon post, just changing the YouTube status to "Public". Alternatively, my other idea would be to simply edit the Patreon post to change from the Vimeo to the YouTube link after the EA period is over.

Michael Graf

Hi David, maybe you could ask the Patreon staff about this issue which is probably a common one?

Nimboon

You could charge everyone for the early access release, and then not charge for the actual release. If it's only about a day early I can't see it upsetting too many people.

MagikGimp

This is usually how it's done. It's a nice gesture to make an effort with passwords and whatnot but at the end of the day, er, that is- it would be only one day, so it's not that big a deal for most patrons I should wager. I think I can speak for the majority in that we want to support content creators above all and getting extras is a nice bonus but not the be all and end all. That's all.

Simon the Delusional

You could upload the film earlier on youtube, keeping it unlisted and posting a link in a post that is only available to $5 people and above (Patreon lets you post things only to certain tiers) people could still leak it but there really isn't any way to make sure that it never leaks.

remove early access as a feature, make a different $5 reward, problem solved

David Firth

No. I don't want the $5+ post to ever go public because it links to a different version of the video - a password protected version that is only for early access people. The one for everyone else will be on Youtube.

Arron Craig

It appears you can set up an EA post that goes public after x number of days. <a href="https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/115001971426-How-do-I-setup-an-early-access-post-" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://patreon.zendesk.com/hc/en-us/articles/115001971426-How-do-I-setup-an-early-access-post-</a> Is this what you meant?

David Firth

It is informative but doesn't address the main part of the problem which is the time difference between the 2 releases. Early access needs to be at least a day early in my opinion.

Arron Craig

This may help David, Probs not though. <a href="https://www.reddit.com/r/patreon/comments/69bi77/how_tier_rewards_work/" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.reddit.com/r/patreon/comments/69bi77/how_tier_rewards_work/</a>

jou

I don't have an answer, but be assured that i wouldn't remove my pledge between the 2 videos... that would be just mean man

Brian Gama

I'm pretty sure you'll want to charge once it's officially released on the 30th. Though in doing so, hopefully people won't back out before you release. Then again, it's only one day, not much time for anything major to happen

Aleks

Just post the link and password as a message to all $5 tier + people, or not? Alternatively, why not release it on Patreon using the standard early access mechanism? If a punk really wants to leak it one day ahead, he will also manage to leak a PW protected one.

Ceecee Costly

Good question...know this isn't much help but love the tags

V3XXE

I've seen different Patreon pages do it differently. A few do the messages, some post the preview up here then don't post it on the release day so it just gets released on YouTube then. If you are wanting to password protect it then messaging is probably the safest bet!

David Firth

Is that the normal way of doing it? That's probably the best option really.

John

Whatever your decision I'm looking forward to viewing the release

David Firth

I'm certainly not going to be charging anyone extra. I think I might just post the early access link without charging and hope the nice folks stay with me.

David Firth

yeah I should have asked them earlier - it says "due to a large volume of queries - answers may take 2 working days" . Anyway I think I can work it out if no one knows.