Post "Murphy's Luck" by "thehouseofhalliwell" from patreon

John Maher

What was clear to me in this episode is that Shannen should be the one winning Academy Awards. She’s an excellent actress. Elevates everything she does.

Ezabel Holmes

This was a deep storyline; bringing awareness to mental health, and showing the girls vulnerabilities! it was an amazing episode. I agree with Holly, the outfits sucked!

Brianna Buth

Wow! I needed to hear some of the things in this podcast today. Y’all rock and I am so glad y’all are here. 💜

Charlotte

"I don't know why we didn't get to vanquish him [The magazine guy]": hahaha well said! So unnecessarily aggressive!

Charlotte

I had a similar thought. Though, I don't think they said their soul go to hell, but more so that they can't become a whitelighter

reece catlin

I have a little grievance with the writers of this episode saying that if you commit suicide, you lose your soul and go to Hell. very insensitive for people struggling with depression. and if there is a God and if he is loving, why would he send people in pain and suffering with depression to hell.

Alysa Curtis

I like how you guys talk about working with Amy in this one but don’t address working with the amazing Arnold Vosloo. You literally had The Mummy in the same episode as Amy who was a bigger star at the time this was filmed! He did such an amazing job in this EP and was my favorite dark lighter.

Anastasia Yates

Same here, heard word merch and can't find the link

Stephanie Barrett

I'm on Brian's side. Angels have "needs" too. How else did they have two kids?

DestyniDreams `

I’m also an ordained minister! Got mines online too. So if you need me let me know! 😄

OK

Such a powerful moment when Prue turns around and tells the demon, "how dare you mess with people this way?"! She truly learned that he had no real power over her the moment she questioned the orgins of her negative self-thought. 💯 Always tell yourself a good and kind story about you and be the type of friend you enjoy being to others to yourself as well 😊

Liz

This episode had a lot to it. It definitely hit hard on mental health, which wasn't really seen as much at this time. There is still that stigma today, but its definitely gotten better. I'm not sure what I'd rate this one. I do love how Prue kind of found her calling with photography. We do get to see how easy it really is for evil to take hold. We all struggle at some point in our lives and this episode definitely shows that. Even if it was evil magnifying it, we still all have those moments whether we want to admit it or not.

Ellen

Leo weddings in Vegas? 🙋🏻‍♀️ Put me in coach

Steph Youthed

I love the discussion around mental health and the inner thoughts we all have. The quote Holly mentioned is so true, but I'd rephrase it to 'judge yourself by who you were yesterday, not by who someone else is today' 🥰

Alicia

Haven't watched it yet. Couldn't tell from the podcast.

Emily Spitz

Best HOH episode yet

Fuiono Ching Sung

She was everywhere in this episode. What do you mean?

Alicia

Was Phoebe I this episode?

Jasmine cortes

Id go to Vegas to marry drew! 😏

Amanda Sterner

Just catching up. Did he say the Merch store is open? I can’t find a link!

Joanna Go

Hello HOH family! Is the watch party on Friday still happening? There will be a link on the patreon page? Thank you for your response!

Elisha Forrest

I think HMC needs her own separate scale for a production rating. Lol.

Elisha Forrest

Piper would never sit on the sidelines either. That's why they are so good together. They both want someone to love them, but they have too much love to only spend it on each other.

Elisha Forrest

I'm for Leo getting his job back! Piper would not have stayed with Leo long if he hadn't gone back to white lighter status! Healer, helper, unsung hero. That's who Leo was and who Piper was at heart too. If he was satisfied with no identity of his own just working for her and being her boyfriend, she would have been over him REAL fast.

Krista

To be part of HMC's world would be awesome. They are so lucky. I loved this episode when it aired but I love it even more now that I recognize the actors. I didn't notice the changes Holly was talking about because I watch for their emotions not their wardrobe.

Jen

I agree, Gloria! Thanks for sharing your thoughts :)

Jen

Ooooh, thanks Jacqui! I did not know any of that so that's awesome to know :) Also - sooo jealous you're going to a con with Alyssa and Julian soon. Hope you have the best time! One of these days I need to plan a trip to the US around a con haha.

Jen

Yep, you're right Linda! We absolutely have zero idea what it was like for them as humans behind the scenes. Us fans can only hope that she will be on at some point hehe :)

claudia

has there been anymore talk about a watch party for chick flick? is that still gonna happen? just curious cause i know the episode is coming up! soo thankful for this podcast it’s made me love the show that much more with all the behind the scenes stuff and stories

Elisa Brogren

I love that Drew thinks his hair stayed the same throughout his whole time on Charmed. He basically had a new hairstyle each episode 😅

Allan Laversane

Hi Milor, thanks a lot for thinking of me :) I'm in the group now!!

Melanie Cabrera

Amazing episode.

Yen Delgado

I grew up memorizing that spell as a teenager and I still know it to this day. That’s how amazing Amy Adams is. She was so into her character. This episode sealed it for me as a fan.

Janine Krispin Deiermann

Thanks!

Milor Echasse

as soon as the web site is online, the HOH will do a post here I believe ;)

Milor Echasse

not on line yet

Milor Echasse

Hi 👋🏻 can’t ask you as a FB friend,, but there a group for producers there : https://m.facebook.com/groups/hohprod/?ref=share

Milor Echasse

Hi Steven, there is a FB group for producers if you wanna join (I asked to be your "friend" on FB so that I can invite U - I don't know how else to do it sorry, you can not be my fb friend anymore after if you want, no problem)

Felisha Cliff

Love the emotion from Prue this episode! Love that the sisters were able to help her through this and that Leo got his powers back to help.

Erin Marie

This was a very strong episode, you guys handled the topic of mental health beautifully. Drew…I had this conversation with my husband about his hair and the same applies to you. You look very handsome with buzzed hair, but for the love of god do you know how many men would kill for your hairline?! Rock it man.

Dawn Mead

BK singing Sublime though ❤️❤️❤️

Gloria Strait of Juan de Fuca

Hell, as long as it's an open bar, I'm in! LoL

Sarah Webster

Anytime if you hear about any merch give me a shout I would love some new merch 🙂xxxx

Gloria Strait of Juan de Fuca

Good question... I haven't seen Alyssa in any of the con's for Charmed over the years. She adored Julian and scenes with him so no surprise she will appear with him (read about her gushing over the kissing scenes hehe). I suppose since the door is open on the podcast she may come in, or not. I know in the entertainment biz there's lots of guessing on things most of us are all too busy with our own personal lives to give much thought about. I'm sure if she wants to be here she will. It's always nice to be appreciated and valued. I'm confident she knows that her fans are here too. 😊

Janine Krispin Deiermann

Hi, thank you! I actually have my candle, I guess I misunderstood - I thought there was more merch! It’s been a long week 🙃 thanks again!!

Sarah Webster

There's a website they do a white lighter candle too I am just patreon member I had to scroll.back to find xxxx

Sarah Webster

Hiya Janine I ordered my box of shadows candle on this post hope it helps https://www.patreon.com/posts/exclusive-bos-82468696

Janine Krispin Deiermann

Can anyone tell me where to find the merch store? 😬 had to watch this week’s ep while cleaning/packing to put my house on the market and I feel like I either missed where it is or misheard that it’s live when it’s actually not.

Janine Krispin Deiermann

Titanic references always.

Jacqui Bennett

I watched a con Q&A panel on YT with Alyssa where she says that Holly had called her to tell her about the podcast (before it started) & that she had an open invitation to go on it & that she would love to if their schedules ever allowed. I think Holly, BK, Drew, Shannen & Rose have remained closer simply because they do more cons together & therefore travel together & spend more time together since Charmed finished. Alyssa tends to do her cons alone (although she is doing one with Julian in Sept & I’m lucky enough to be going - my Charmed autos in my BOS will be complete 😊)

Linda MacKinnon

I’ve been wondering the same thing! There’s been no mention of Alyssa coming on as a guest & there seems to be, dare I say it, less affection? But in reality, we are seeing charmed from a different perspective. We created relationships with the characters, whereas the cast lived it as themselves, with ups & downs & experiences that we never saw. ❤️

Allan Laversane

I’m so glad to be a producer of HOH and to make a tiny contribution for this beautiful community of longtime fans! You guys are genuinely the best, this show and what you’ve done have brought a lot to us throughout the years 🫶 Plus, I LOVE how you are also sharing memories and talking about Shannen cause yeah, she is one of the best actors out there and she put her mark on Charmed. Hoping to see her pop up at some point 🤞 (Rose and Alyssa too of course!) Sending you all good vibes, cheers!

Jen

Amazing podcast ep and ep of Charmed :) has anyone else noticed that they rarely ever talk about Alyssa or memories with her? Makes me wonder if she will ever be on as a guest. Especially seeing as they have already said that Shannon, and even Rose, will be guests at some point. Hopefully I'm just reading into nothing and Alyssa will be too - fingers crossed!! Haha

Steven Maggiolino

I love this podcast, and Charmed, so much I changed my subscription so I could be named a "producer". For myself it's worth it. The appreciation I feel for this series, and the hosts of this podcast warranted it. Thank you Holly, Brian, and Drew for providing us all with this great gift.

Linda MacKinnon

Wow!! This episode really struck some chords! Thank you for the beautiful words of wisdom from all three of you! 🥰 As a person who battle’s anxiety on a daily basis, it was wonderful to hear that I’m not alone in my crazy thought processes! Who knew that a podcast from a 20 yr old TV show could become therapy!! Love to all of you ❤️❤️❤️

Imogen Guild

Random but did anyone else catch a glimpse of TW King in Oppenheimer? 😆

Petr Pronsati

I hadn’t rewatched the first two seasons in a few years. It’s fun revisiting how amazing Shannen is. Most of my top episodes from the first three seasons are ones that are Prue-focused. Can’t wait for Primrose Empath in season 3.

Mattel Woods

Phoebe Pixie was my all time favorite. Along with Blonde Prue, Ginger Lob Paige, andddd The Evolution of Piper’s Bangs

Leslie

Glad to hear that Jamen is doing better! This was a good episode, another interpretation on the inner voice conflict that I got was that even though the voice in your head sounds like you, that doesn’t mean it is you. The dark lighter changed his voice and your brain thinks up crazy things. Like Holly mentioned you are not your brain, and a lot of the times your brain will be meaner to you than others. So, treat yourself as you would others with kindness, respect, and grace. Loved all the insights from you guys on this episode and Drew’s tip for mindfulness. In a world that’s constantly moving to the next thing it’s nice to just take a few moments to really be present. I agree with Sando! I am so glad that Brian’s audio is better.

Sarah Webster

Ha ha holly made me laugh so much with the wings ha ha why does Leo keep leaving you annoying xxxxx

Desiree Bradburn

I was at the convention in Tennessee it was so awesome to see HMC and listen in on your panel! Thank You!! On Adrian Paul’s panel I am the one who asked about his charmed episode :D Such a great weekend! Hope you like your goat earrings!! 🐐

Claire Horton

I always seem to miss the lives 🙄

Gloria Strait of Juan de Fuca

The amazing Mr. Arnold Vosloo - the darklighter was so convincing and frightening - agreed he didn't need to shoot things out of his hands at all! Amazing actor. It would have been cool to have him on as a guest, although if he's living in South Africa now and the time zones might be an issue. Shannen is so amazing in everything - and this episode like the other one John directed, wasn't it P3 H20, delved into so many of our deepest fears and wounds and she nails it every time. (Note on Brian's son - so happy to hear he's on the way on repairs. I call my son the bionic man now (plates and pins in his ankle, pins in tibia, plate and rod in fibula) and yes the bathing issue is really tough. Once his cast is off though he will be able to shower much easier and will be much happier. He was so happy when we got his hair washed and cut in acute care once he was out of ICU. Hang in there dad, you're doing the good work and Jamen will be so much stronger and heal so much faster surrounded by all the love he's getting from family and friends!)

Sandro

Brian! I'm only four minutes in - I must say I'm so glad your audio is a million times better. I've said from the beginning you have such an incredible way of explaining things and telling stories. Beautiful to hear how your son is recovering. And that accent transition... I love how Drew is a Prue stan. I can relate. Thank you, the entire ep of the podcast was fantastic.

Annie O’Malley

What is the merch websites. Inwould love to see what they have. I love my candles

Annie O’Malley

As always love ya. You guys are awesome. This episode was epic .

Laura Shergold

Oh you guys 🥺 Feel like I felt all sorts of emotions watching this. Love the unique way you can go from talking about the heavier topics (with wise insights) to having me laughing and smiling so much ❤️ Drew’s “I thought we were in the safe tree…safe triquetra” 😂 BK mentioned on a previous ep we should reach out when we struggle and since listening to the pod I’ve made some lovely Charmed/HoH pals and it’s been so good having not only a common interest but people to help support us when needed ❤️Thank you for helping us connect. Glad to hear Jamen is making progress! I am SO excited for merch - will definitely have to be repping it for P3iP! Episode wise - I thought Amy was fantastic - the way she seemed so terrified on the roof 😬 Did wonder how no-one seemed to comment on the sudden sideways falling - that must have looked sus! Loved the Piper and Leo scenes too of course!

Brianna Roberts

So glad your son is doing better Brian. This is a great episode. Holly, I love that jeeped fallowed you to ppl.

Jacqui Bennett

Thanks for the Jamen update- so glad his recovery is continuing so well! Yet another brilliant HOH episode. I love getting sucked in to your musings. I find myself nodding, saying to myself ‘Yes!’ Or ‘Omg, I do that too!’ I love how truthful, honest & authentic you guys are about all things. Then I’ll be laughing hysterically next! I rated the Murphy’s Luck an 8.5/9 VEGAS BABY!! 😁

Stefanie Celeste

I love that I’m at the age now where I can say I’ll happily marry Drew or BK in Vegas! Let’s go gents! Yay for “Elder” Millennials ...see what I did there too. ;) #forevercharmed

Ryan Byrum

Anna Faris in Smiley Face is amazing ✨

Anjee Campbell

Omg. I want to get remarried just so "Leo" can officiate 😆

Milor Echasse

not yet

Ryan Byrum

The advice given here is so profoundly accurate to many peoples internal struggles 🙏💕 great episode!

Rachel Krawsek

Wonderful episode and GREAT podcast recap

Anjee Campbell

I am so glad to hear Jamen is doing better!! I loved this episode! The only thing that threw me a bit was how quickly everything happened. Like would someone go from being a basically happy person to being ready to jump in just one day? It seemed to happen too fast. It is one of my faves though.

Charlotte

Anyone Have Merch website?

Lu Reason

BK so glad to hear Jamen has continued to recover!! 🖤 Love this episode of charmed and really enjoyed listening to you guys talk about it! It was annoying that Leo become a whitelighter as soon as Piper had made her decision.. but he was definitely the right choice! I’m really looking forward to episode 18 chick flick, it’s one of my faves!! Also Drew and BK I’m probably too young to marry you guys (even for an hour 😂) so I will just come to Vegas and watch the weddings instead haha 😂😂

Andrew Chavis

Oh yeah that’s another great one. Or when Piper reads an avatar and elder in vaya con leos. Another great Piper scene.

Ariadne Bene

The one that always gets me though and almost always manages to get me to tear up is at the end of Oh My Goddess Part 2 when she confronts Leo about becoming an elder. Holly can always pull at my heart strings with her emoting.

Ariadne Bene

It really DID feel like decades Drew with this triangle. Like, it's been 84 years with it 🥴

Andrew Chavis

Between that scene and their scene season 4 episode 1. Just so beautifully acted and emotional. Just love it so much.

Ariadne Bene

I forgot about that scene at the end with Piper crying and Leo holding her. That broke my heart.

Andrew Chavis

All this Leo shade. Just wait until the end of Astral Monkey. Such a great scene with Piper and Leo. Thank you for updating us on your son’s recovery BK, it’s such a relief to know he’s been improving and hoping this will be the last of the surgeries.

Carolina Orellana Villarroel

Thanks you guys

Milor Echasse

BK we'll follow U anywhere. Drew, I vote yes angels have libido. And I'm french, I'll get you married in the Holy Chapel if needed. I m old Dr Fuller, with 4 teenagers/young adults kids at home, my mindfullness is cooking/baking. I actually have to hide to listen to the podcast, so that everybody at home knows I am NOT available... Drew, each and everytime you're doing the "meee?", can't stop from seeing Scoobidoo in my head :D PAtreon 's perk accepted, or you can do it on Cameo boys ! Big hug to Jamen from France.

Roanne Grech

Producer Perk. Get married to Drew. Have BK officiate.

Kate

Awwww, thanks!! :-)

Steven Maggiolino

Shannen's performance was extraordinary. I truly felt the emotion she was exhibiting. This is a personal favorite episode of mine. One that I watch often. It was also a treat to see guest stars like Amy Adams, and Arnold Vosloo. Amy was a rising star, and Arnold had just starred in the huge film The Mummy. This will always be a special episode for me. Thank you for the update on Jamen, who remains in the best of healing thoughts. Love to Shannen. Love to all. Keep up the great work. My rating is a solid 10. A standout episode. Plus we get to see Piper and Leo reunite. YEA!!!!

Kazz (Charmed4lifekaren)

Omg, i was smiling throughout this entire ep. Loved it.

stacey ✨

Instead of a M&G, its an M&A. Get married, take wedding pics, get annulment. 😂

Maria Wilson

I’d have Brian perform my marriage ceremony lol. 😝 ps: kinda missed the goat lol 😂

Katey Huss

I’m heading to Vegas next year Drew. I’ll meet you guys there ☺️

Rebecca Goldfinch

I am half way through watching this podcast absolutely awesome 😎. Great talk about the hard issues such as depression, suicide and fears which are very relevant societal issues both at the time this episode was made and now. It was great that this episode approached the topic in a creative but sensitive way very groundbreaking!