FapsCommunity
kamikazepotato from patreon
kamikazepotato patreon

Demonic Conqueror: Heroic Valor - Chapter 1

🕑 Added 2024-07-13 05:11:36 +0000 UTC

Comments

Jag Sandhu

Just when I think I'm out, you reel me back in.

Zachary Sloan

My potentially negative feedback here (I say "potentially" because it depends entirely upon the future direction of the story*) is that it's not entirely clear to me whether the reader is supposed to consider Simon's perspective reasonable. The idea of "creating positive change through getting rich and bribing politicians" is inherently kind of silly (it's basically similar to the ideology of people like Sam Bankman-Fried - "Effective Altruism" - plus a flawed understanding of how consent is created/reinforced, both in the government and society as a whole), but I'm not sure if the narrative is "aware" of this, if that makes sense. Are we supposed to think of Simon as an eccentric rational/analytical person, or as "a young person who fancies themselves rational/analytical but is actually pretty ignorant/naive"? One interesting direction I could see this going is that, from my perspective, Simon's views reflect a fundamentally egotistical viewpoint. He wants to make the world ("a world" in this case) a better place, but it seems important to him that "he be directly responsible for making it better." He never considers working with other people, despite that being a more effective way to improve the world than "independently earning a lot of money" (which is far more likely to involve causing harm, since there's no way to become "rich to the point where you can influence the government" without exploiting a ton of people along the way). * I didn't like Adam at the start of Skill Thief for example, but the story later explains why he is the way he is (and he ends up changing in various ways)

Zachary Sloan

If you were to continue saving money (and enough money to buy other properties, even) from renting out a property, by definition your rates wouldn't be "reasonable" - all the money going into your future properties is just being siphoned off of the tenants. It's like living in a society with vampires and trying to address the problem by sucking blood yourself and then donating a portion of it - in the end you're still a net negative, even if you might not be quite as bad as the ones who don't donate any. Simon's idea is wrong for a somewhat different reason - he fundamentally misunderstands how political power works. Politicians don't do things just because those things make them money. That's a factor, but they'll still only ever be willing to do things that are tolerated by the people and institutions with power in their society. If you gave millions of dollars to every member of Congress and told them to implement (for example) a single-payer healthcare system, the vast majority would still refuse. Because even if it technically means less money for them, they benefit from society's various powerful institutions (and have spent their entire lives internalizing the ideology of the society in which they live).

Kerrus Magrus

When people die they shit themselves. If that didn't happen here it might deserve a mention for humor.

KamikazePotato

Thanks for the feedback! I'll try to think of a more punch-ier ending...although it's difficult because Simon's circumstances are very different than Rob's. Simon chose this, and even chose this knowing it would be a bad situation right away, and he's happy with the results. A cliffhanger ending wouldn't work as well when the protagonist is jumping headfirst into the deep end. With that said, there are some ideas I can play with. Thanks again!

KamikazePotato

Glad you enjoyed it! As for your comments on the ambiguity regarding Simon's character - that was intentional. My goal was for the reader not to have a full idea of what *exactly* his deal is, but to leave enough so that people would be interested in finding out more as the story progresses. Would you say that succeeded for you, or were you instead more confused in an unenjoyable way?

Mel

Ok...what to write. Really thinking about this and mostly about that you wanted to hear negative feedback. I really liked the parts: introduction of the mc, the introduction of the background/system, the first adventure in the world. The story got me hooked, more then Skill Thief. But I wanted to write negative feedback (because this is what makes a story better) and I really had to think about it. So after reading the story several times: I think the end is lacking. Can't put my thumb on it, but it could be better (or not and its just my dumb feeling). Somehow the (real good) hook is missing. If I compare it to Rob, he got a note with "Good Luck" and was thrown into an unknown world. And the reader didn't know what was coming next. Maybe this is what I am thinking. Ok thinking about this, you were very skillful in getting the right amount of "cliffhanger" in the story. Not to low, not to high. Maybe this is the right ending. Just my humble thoughts :) P.S. As I re-read Rob Ch.1 again....damm...your writing was good, now it is just miles ahead from where you started.

Jonathan Crandall

Oh now I can't wait for this one. Got me hooked from the start. Beginning with something as relatable as a customer with the emotional maturity of an 8 year old was brilliant. I think we can all agree on collectively hating them. I'm glad Simon isn't just a copy of Rob. He seems like a completely unique character (honestly the God was probably talking about Rob in his example of who should be taken). I love novels with good political intrigue and this looks like it's going to be one of them

Arillius

I came to similar conclusions that Simon did, funny enough, about systematic change. The big issue I found with the 'bribe politicians' plan was quite literally the money plan. In order to acquire enough money to affect anything larger than a town or perhaps city election, you would need hundreds of millions at least. And the only way to acquire that much is to add to the world's suffering. I wasn't on track to make that much money, but I was on track for a healthy amount of savings, and nothing to spend it on. My eventual goal became 'purchase a large property and rent at reasonable prices'. Actually reasonable, not 'modern day reasonable'. That would allow me to save enough to eventually purchase another property. The idea was that I couldn't create systemic change, but I could improve the lives of dozens, including families, by making a place that would rent at affordable rates for those stuck working minimum wage, cheap enough that they could start saving and living their lives. Of course, life has a way of saying 'fuck you' whenever you are doing well, so now my goals are back to basics for survival once more. So all in all, I find Simon's refrain about wanting to change the world a very 1 to 1 and now I am very much hoping he is on the spectrum like I am, because it's not often you get an autistic hero that's not some cliched genius/idiot savant.

Arillius

And yeah Simon seems like he’s sociopathic, I don’t think he’s on the spectrum though. Extremely sharp witted and aware. I think he’ll fare well in the medieval political games to come. Two things wrong with this. 1. Sociopathic people are not people that care about others, in small or in large. 2. Saying that he's not on the spectrum because he's 'sharp witted and aware' is probably one of the most bigoted things I've heard said or read about people like myself in years.

Gabriel Steel

already got me hook, line and sinker! the beginning is amazing, getting you invested in the story with humour, and the prospect of being the only person in that world with a skill system is always interesting to me. on a side note, that "transmigrator's body" perk seems VERY useful! i also hope for more funny interactions wiht sky-voice or similar :D

NnT042

I like it. There's only so many traditional ways to yoink someone to an isekai, and this seems like a logical escalation from Rob's "taken through a portal in broad daylight with no warning". Now we have "announced on planetwide PA like it's the Vogon fleet or something" and it's brilliant. I'm also intrigued by the little hints of what is going on with the gods and their rules of engagement. Maybe with bad guys taking loopholes our MC can end up with some sort of extra benefit down the line if he takes a moment to teach voice guy to do the same.

Yuppie_Indentured_Servant

This was a fantastic first chapter. The Voice-In-The-Sky interaction with the people of Earth was brilliantly done. The humor in the interactions between a godly existence and random people from Earth was fun, and the black-and-white outline of the world with a supreme good and supreme evil fighting it out with mortal pawns all felt fresh and exciting. The transition, system, and fight scene with the rat are all fantastic! Simon’s skills seem geared toward a brawler and taken with the opening scene, it paints an interesting picture of what Simon’s character might end up looking like. The opening scene and talk with Grace felt a little at odds. The retail scene depicts a hothead who lashes out in a pretty low-stakes environment. When confronted with a verbally abusive customer, he returns the abuse in kind, likely not making the world a better place. I like the humor of the interaction, but the immediate follow-up of his manager offering a recommendation and the talk with Grace (at a soup kitchen, so he is good?) paints the picture of a (good?) employee who, maybe naively, believes that he can make lasting systemic change if he has enough money. It is unclear from his thoughts whether the change he wants is good or bad or if he has the maturity to decide what is good or bad. The conversation with the Voice-In-The-Sky mid-transit only further muddies Simon’s motivations. Is he a hero or a power-crazed lunatic? The Voice-In-The-Sky is convinced he will be good for the planet, but Simon acts kinda deceitfully, so it's unclear if the Voice-In-The-Sky is being hoodwinked or not. The brawler-type skills make me think that Simon could have a cool punk character arc with some character flaws that see growth throughout the story. It makes sense to get to the action as quickly as possible, but I also want to see more detail of Simon's character before the isekai. Hearing his thought process when dealing with the customer or extending the conversation with Grace could add a little depth to what seems like a somewhat cold calculating character from just the opening chapter. I am excited to see where the story goes and appreciate the chapter! I really enjoy reading your work and hope that you find my feedback on it helpful.

TheArchivist

Very very much enthralled with this story And yeah Simon seems like he’s sociopathic, I don’t think he’s on the spectrum though. Extremely sharp witted and aware. I think he’ll fare well in the medieval political games to come. I don’t know enough to know if Simon is necessarily charismatic or personable, but it could be dependent on who he interacts with.


More Creators