Hbomb patreon

What Makes An Action Scene Good?

🕑 Added 2016-06-30 23:54:22 +0000 UTC

Comments

I love it! Very well-written and thoughtful! (I feel like I'm grading an english essay. -_-)

MrXeno

Really enjoyed this. Would love to see more like this and your FO3 retrospective.

Ran Schvartz

I consider the Avengers movie to be entertaining, but not great. I saw it and didn't think about what kept it from greatness, You make a good point about the sloppiness of certain action directors.

boy_carmelina

I liked it. Even for someone who's only curious about film theory, the video was captivating. I will say, though, that I found it a bit basic for my liking. For example, the idea that implied action might be more effective than explicit action seems obvious to me (because I must've encountered it elsewhere on Youtube or in an article). But your point on zooming until the frame is dominated by a tiny pistol to give it impact is new to me. I suppose I prefer your essays to be more specific and technical. Your comedy would help make technical and abstract topics more palatable for someone like me who never studied film.

Ruben Rydell-Sandgren

Oh, good stuff (even if that Whedon-pun was THE WORST JOKE YOU'VE EVER PULLED, sir). In all honesty though, I prefer your thoughts on film when you're on the Smug Film Podcast. Simply because I find discussions about films to be more interesting than video essays. But hey, more content about cinema either way is win-win. Oh, and another example of someone who does great comedic action stuff: Edgar Wright.

Nick V.

Also, great video as always. I'm assuming the sequel to this will be about how practical effects beat CG effects in every way imaginable, but that's just a guess.