historyunderground
patreon
Censored
🕑 Added 2023-02-04 20:42:45 +0000 UTC
I'm sure that by now, you've all seen the circus that I've found myself in over the past few days concerning the age restriction that was placed on the Dachau video. I honestly can't believe that this is where we are, but it is what it is.
Every time something like this happens, I get a flood of people telling me to go to Rumble. What they don't know is that I'm already on Rumble and have a few videos posted there. I'm going to continue to build that channel out. But to be honest, Rumble isn't exactly awesome although there have been some improvements lately to their platform. My goal has always been to reach as many people with historic content as possible. If I were to completely disconnect from YouTube and go solely to Rumble, I would be shooting myself in the foot. Ideally, I'd like to see some reforms at YouTube but making changes from within is proving difficult. I think that something big is going to have to happen where they get pressure from the outside.
Also, although I'd resisted the idea at first, I'm going to re-upload the Dachau video without the above photo that offended their sensitivities so much. I'm also go to explain why so that people can see what is happening at YouTube.
Our channel isn't the only one that's experiencing this. I've been contacted by numerous other history creators who are experiencing the same thing. I'm not going to go as far as to say that YouTube has Holocaust deniers in their ranks, but their policies are certainly doing the work that a Holocaust denier would be pleased with. At some point, a major media outlet is going to pick up on this and it's going to be a PR nightmare for YouTube.
My other fear (which might be completely unfounded) is that the channel is going to be punished for some of my remarks that I've been making publicly. Yesterday saw a significant decline in new subscribers. Sometimes that just happens. I'm just hoping that there isn't a correlation.
I don't know when the re-upload is going to happen. I'm leaning toward Tuesday or Wednesday. When it happens, I'll need some help getting the word out. Appreciate you all!
Comments
Sent your Patreon Mail -
Hold tight- I’ll send you a message
I would actually be very interested in knowing what they said and where you sent your message through.
Sent YouTube a message- actually heard back from them but don’t know if it will go anywhere. JD - happy to send you a message to the Patreon channel mail if you’re interested in knowing what was said. Rest assured that I kept it above board (no pettiness) and tried to make sure I got my message across about the absurdity of censoring the content you went out of your way to keep it within guidelines.
keep up the good fight if a human actually watched your videos there would be no problem
So, YouTube is censoring that photo from pre-teens who play shoot-em-up videos games that desensitizes them to violence?
Vlogging Through History
So frustrating. Thanks for fighting this battle and bringing these stories and locations to us!
JD let us know what we can do. I am 100% behind you and this channel. I hope together we can get YouTube to reach acceptance of the content. The idea that there might be Holocaust deniers in their ranks makes it more imperative that we prevail!
Keep your head down and your prayers up! There was nothing wrong with your content. They need to get rid of some of the half naked videos that seem to be just fine. The cussing on some of the videos my grands get into is disgusting. My rant. Dr. Lou Zemek
No. The original will stay up. I refuse to replace that. The same thing happened awhile back with an American Artifact video that got hit with an age restriction. The original currently has 17,777 views. The re-upload that is sanitized has 96,678 views. I wasn't going to do it but the more I thought about it, the more I convinced myself otherwise. I not only want the people to see the content, but I want them to know what is happening behind the curtain at YouTube.
Very much support what you’re doing and will do what I can to get the word out about the upload. I fear making any plea to YouTube as a subscriber would be a waste of time but I’d vigorously support a campaign to get attention paid to your troubles and those of your peers doing the good work of keeping history front and center. Keep the faith and keep up the great work.
So, does "re-upload" mean you are replacing the existing video with the censored one at the same link or a new video with a new link?
Dustin Wise
We are on your side JD. Keep doing what you are doing although I imagine it is beyond frustrating
