FapsCommunity
Let's Talk Religion from patreon
Let's Talk Religion patreon

The Origins of the Arabic Language

🕑 Added 2021-06-18 07:38:43 +0000 UTC
The Origins of the Arabic Language

Comments

Filip Holm

Thank you for the feedback! It's a combination of time concerns but also the fact that this is outside of my field of expertise, so I can't have the same nuanced and broad approach to the topic. I did my best to summarize the research by scholars like al-Jallad and MacDonald, but I am fully aware that there are many aspects and points that I missed!

Wrik Chatterjee

A couple small criticisms: (1) Did you cut out the detail that Semitic itself is a branch of Afroasiatic because of time concerns? Personally I find it a very eye-opening introduction to the phenomenon of language spreads and language shift that Arabic's more distant relatives include the likes of Hausa, Coptic, or Somali. Related to this is the fact that Arabic likely displaced Coptic and the Amazigh languages so successfully because they are distant relatives and share some typological features in common, such as a templatic format involving vowel interchange. Arabic's displacement of Aramaic in the Levant can doubtless also be partly attributed to the fact that they are (closer) relatives. (2) A mention of the Modern South Arabian languages in Yemen and Oman, such as Jibbali or Mehri, would also have been useful in shedding light on other Semitic languages spoken in the Arabian Peninsula. Overall I really liked it!

Filip Holm

Done.

Filip Holm

As I listened with my headphones, I realized that the music is way too loud in some parts. I'll fix it and replace the current video!


More Creators