FapsCommunity
jackpot_kun from patreon
jackpot_kun patreon

[Young Master Xian]—❈—44:: Climax [VI]

🕑 Added 2025-01-19 21:37:13 +0000 UTC

Comments

Bee

It's emotionally satisfying to see (original cultivator asshole) get crushed

wanderer117

There clearly was another way it could go. Jackpot-kun edited his work so the MC wasn't surrendering for nothing. Now the MC has a fun weakness instead of a terminal case of dumb. I'll try one more time. When a robber pulls a gun and says "Your money and your life" a normal person will fight them even if they are unarmed. Yes, they might lose, they might even be likely to lose but when surrender = death why not try?

George Tasie

I made edits to it.

Daniel

Same.

Zaim İpek

I don't see how the idea of 'credit' factors in. There is no other way things could have gone. This isn't a multiple choice scenario. Every character involved only had a single realistic choice until Xiuying entered the scene. And other course of action would make no sense within the context.

dad

Me too. New edits or something?

Apoca

I got repinged with this chapter

wanderer117

Let's keep this simple then. 'His only option was to stall for time as much as possible. Surrendering accomplished that perfectly. In that same amount of time, he probably would have ripped off another body part and eaten it, but he didn't because he saw Qigang cooperating. Sooo plan = success. ' Are you saying because in the story things worked out that is to the MC's credit?

Monus

I actively skim all fight scenes in all stories. I would in fact prefer if people just stopped writing fight scenes and only tell me the outcome. They tend do drag on for the most part and don't really matter. So maybe just make the MC a buff and affliction monster and let's move on :P

Zaim İpek

I struggle to see your point or understand your question. I was trying to explain what was happening in the story, and explain why attacking would have been the worse choice for Qigang since you didn't seem to understand why he surrendered. It's likely that it would have been game over if Xiuying didn't arive when she did. That's the point of the scene. It's called tension and setting up the scene. There was no choice Qigang could have made that would let him "win". He fell into a very well crafted trap by a villain who is actually competent at being evil. The face it would have been game over without Xiuying is largely the point of this chapter. Is there confusion about that?

Zaim İpek

Eh, Qigang has special powers that aren't fully understood, even by himself. Maybe she thought he might have a chance of figuring something out if he stopped focusing on saving her. It might be that cultivation rank factors in, and while her cultivation and Xiuying's is too inferior to brute force the exit, she thought Qigang might have a chance with his higher cultivation quality and rank.

George Tasie

Yet another thing I shall deliberate upon under the Waterfalls of Serenity. 😔 Why is writing so hard?

Kevin Rule

This is a good fight scene, I think the problem is that you may be thinking to much of other cultivation stories that are heavy in terms of combat. Those get boring after they stretch on too long and then they get a bit ridiculous, short and to the point is fine

wanderer117

@Zaim Not sure what you are arguing for here? Are you saying because in the story things worked out that is to the MC's credit? We heard his inner dialog, that was not a calculated plan. That was panic then surrender. '“Stop,” I scream. “Stop. Please, stop.” The fire surrounding me winks out, and I raise my arms in surrender. I can’t watch that again. I just can’t.' If Meng Yi didn't have plot armor, if the MC didn't have plot armor, if Xiuying did not arrive exactly when she did that's game over. None of the other cultivators present are capable of dealing with evil MC. A mutilated MC is not winning a fight against his evil version and everyone else is multiple times weaker then he is.

Scipio

Quick question / plot hole. Why does she tell him to run when later in the chapter it says literally the opposite, that they can't leave without demon Qigang's permission? What if he *had* run, wouldn't he have just died tired since he couldn't actually escape? Liked the chapter though, just a bit of an inconsistency.

Franco R

Heck, you could even skip the fight scene for now, have them deal with the fall out and then have the fight scene come back in pieces like ptsd throughout more chapters. That way you don’t have to focus so long on it each time

Zaim İpek

You don't seem to have grasped the situation. Qigang is thoroughly in love. That means Meng Yi's life is more important that his own. Attacking would mean instant death for her, so that option was automatically out. His only option was to stall for time as much as possible. Surrendering accomplished that perfectly. In that same amount of time, he probably would have ripped off another body part and eaten it, but he didn't because he saw Qigang cooperating. Sooo plan = success. His actions are exactly what they should have been. You have the illusion that before Xiuying arrived, he had the possibility of ensuring Meng Yi's life. No. There was no possibility of that. It wasn't .001%. It was 0%. And he was going to be tortured first, that's a significant amount of time in which Meng Yi would not be the focus of attention. In that there may have been a .01% chance of reversing the situation. That's what he was hoping for. It was his only real opinion before Xiuying entered the scene and tipped the balance.

Zaim İpek

You are a liar. This is a fantastic fight scene. Most authors get this part wrong and think describing each move with very elaborate language is what connects the reader. It's not. What connects the reader to a fight scene is feeling the emotion of the main character behind each action. Feeling surprised when the MC is surprised. Feeling angry when the MC is angry. Feeling successful when the MC feels successful. And you do that PERFECTLY here. I think I felt every emotion of Qigang from watching Meng Yi's finger get ripped off and eaten, to Xiuying suddenly appearing and joining the fight, to finally seeing hope and jumping at the opportunity as soon as it arrived to mount a full-force counter attack, to the moment of cathartic rage mixed with tension of punching the demon bastard in the face. This is exactly how a fight scene should be written. You are a better writer than you give yourself credit. I am also realizing right now that you created a situation where Qigang and Meng Yi are perfectly compatible for "dual cultivation" due to how he altered her cultivation.

wanderer117

But the hostage taker's counter offer was surrender and I will killer her painfully. So if he acts and she dies he hasn't lost anything, if he acts and she lives he's saved her and himself. There is no down side. Young Masters aren't worth talking to or negotiating with 90% of the time since the main reason they are Young Masters is their poor grasp that other people are people and not toys.

MagicWafflez

ehhhh, he had ming yi hostage... there wasn't anything he could do to stop hom without him threatening ming yi's life... it'll be better now that she is away from danger I think.

marconjecture

Goat's cheese is delicious! And I really like your fight scenes!

wanderer117

What kind of story / scene are you trying to write? The MC standing helpless while Meng Yi is tortured is ruff. Like, is this our hero? Someone that gives up when faced with hardship? It's not like other him is offering to spare Meng Yi, he's actively hurting her right now so doing nothing feels extra bad and surrendering feels even worse. Then the MC is set up to solo other him once Xiuying arrives and carries Meng Yi away? So he was strong enough to win the hole time but he gave up rather then trying? Like delaying other him until Xiuying arrived then working with her and ideally Meng Yi to win the fight would be a friendship is magic story line. The MC soloing his other self without giving up would be a better then his worst self story line. Then you could have Xiuying come in while the fight is ongoing and free Meng Yi. There are lots of ways to write the fight to tell different stories, but I'm not sure what story you are trying to tell.

George Tasie

It is? Well, um... Okay. That's news to me honestly. I'm glad you think so though.

Oskar Nordström

Please don't be a goat herder. Meng Yi would have to come to you and talk about your weekly efficiency with a judgemental stare

Snuckytoes

“I’m terrible at fight scenes”. ->Proceeds to write a fantastic and engaging fight scene.


More Creators