FapsCommunity
Professor Quill from patreon
Professor Quill patreon

Update! And a new poll!

🕑 Added 2025-09-30 19:39:01 +0000 UTC

Comments

Professor Quill

Unfortunately, it wasn't that popular

ahirzy007

What about dangerous games?

Brian Jordan

I understand your comments but somehow feel obliged to discuss your views on Gilded Legacy. Not that I'm overly enamored with the story idea but because how it's told would matter greatly, If we start from her earliest attempts to live up to Lockhart's reputation, I agree: It would be a touch tiresome. (Okay, more than a touch.) But there is no reason to start there. Instead, the tale could begin near the end of her quest. She's started noticing how many things don't fit with what Gilderoy described and ignoring it is getting harder and harder, Also, I can see someone whose relative's memories were wiped by the man and is looking for payback. If the aurors found out someone was hunting the lady, who might be assigned? What would happen next would depend on the storyteller.

manoxis

I quite dislike the idea of the 4th one. The whole "someone else gets the spotlight, again and again" but with specifically the hot magical ladies apparently being able to see right through it time after time - it just sounds *incredibly* implausible (ie., silly), plus the whole "Harry has to bite the humiliation bullet time after time to save the arse of some brat" just sounds so annoying to have to listen to... and then she 'magically' realises she's in love with him at the end and, what, he reciprocates because he's just got that little of a spine? Sorry for thrashing your idea, it just *really* don't see it working out. #2 would have to be from Harry's perspective; I don't think it'd work to have a story where you see it from both Ron's *and* Harry's perspectives. (And I just don't like Ron-centric stories much.) However, if the idea just is to give Suzette a comeback (I would highly approve), I think there's maybe better ways of doing it? #1 is the safe bet. It sounds like you're looking to set it up as a sort of "slice of life" style story? It's nice and workable, and I tend to like Daphne as a character a lot, and it sounds like a fairly non-complicated story, although perhaps running the risk of ending up on the more boring side, plot-wise. This was close to getting my vote, but... #3 gets my vote, only because I have a thing for "lost on a tropical island" type stories generally, for some reason... I'm not so sure about the aging-up thing, at least it being so drastic (sounds like 5-10 years or something for 1-2 months real time - they "built a family"?), because I think the main focus should be on their time on the island, and that sort of invites for a trap in that Harry must then go home and go through a whole other saga of dealing with Voldie. He needs to be gotten rid of in a way that doesn't need the story to continue (much) after they leave the island - maybe there's some wonky interaction with the time-dilation field and the Horcrux in Harry's noggin that makes it forcefully sap Voldieshorts, his other horcruxes, and his marked minions of their magic/life energy, while making Harry stronger? Maybe there's a powerful backlash when it finally kills Voldie, say after a few months (real time), when maybe 1, maybe 2 years has passed on the island, and that "boom" allows the wards to be broken? So when they come to get them finally, they're not really much older (but maybe Tonksie is preggers - oopsie!).

ThDrkWzrd142

Sorry to hear about the injury, definitely would prefer to see new ground with a ephemeral story like Gilded Legacy. Think the folks here are a little stuck on more "standard" premises. Harry and Beauxbaton girls, Daphne, Ron getting ego checked, but exploring the more adult day-to-day dangers of the wizarding world sounds great. Not too sure about one-nights or harem with "monster-girls" also think the premise works a little better if you lean into Harry not wanting headlines or credit rather than a one punch style "no one notices the true power but the ones who can't or won't speak the truth". Just my thoughts.

Hacura

My order would be 2, 1, 3……………..4. Return of Suzette moves 2 above 1. I love her Forever in a Day character.

Salvage48

The first two are the best, the age up thing throws me off the third one, but I do like the gist of it, the fourth one would make a great two - three chapter mini series.

faseastasiascasch

Number 2 for sure, just to see Suzette again.


More Creators